Advocates and lawmakers demand action on the “New York for All” bill, citing a need for police transparency and protection against ICE
BUFFALO, N.Y. — Advocates, lawmakers, and community members gathered outside the Erie County Holding Center on Monday, calling for support of the proposed “New York for All” bill and greater transparency from local law enforcement.
Assemblymember Jonathan Rivera says the legislation would prevent local law enforcement agencies from voluntarily collaborating with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Supporters argue the measure is necessary to protect vulnerable communities and prevent future tragedies.
Rivera pointed to the recent death of Nurul Amin Shah Alam as a driving force behind the renewed push for the bill. Community leaders are criticizing the Erie County Sheriff’s Office, accusing it of a lack of transparency in handling Shah Alam’s case.
“We’ve had a tough time these last few weeks in the community about this death, but we’re more concerned about it happening again,” Rivera said. “The sheriff’s lack of interest or indifference towards being transparent about his process is very concerning.”
Rivera is now calling on the Erie County Legislature to hold a public hearing, urging the sheriff to answer questions about the case. He has also launched a petition to build community support and push for accountability.
Advocates say their goal is clear: ensure that a tragedy like this does not happen again.
2 On Your Side reached out to the Erie County Sheriff’s Office for a statement. This is what they said:
“The New York State Attorney General’s guidance concerning local authorities’ participation in immigration enforcement clearly permits each agency to advise federal authorities consistent with a federal detainer request. This is nothing new. Perhaps Assemblyman Rivera is unaware as a state representative, but we do not treat detainers any differently than the New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision. In February, our Office shared the sequence of events that led to Mr. Shah Alam’s release to United States Border Patrol. As noted, we informed Border Patrol of his impending release pursuant to the detainer. We did not extend his period of local incarceration or delay his release.”