DAUPHIN COUNTY, Pa. (WHP) — A debate over who should pay for security upgrades at Gov. Josh Shapiro’s private residence after the arson at the governor’s mansion in Harrisburg is now urging a proposal aimed at preventing similar disputes for future governors. Republican Sen. Jarrett Coleman is pushing for what he calls more transparency and accountability in how security-related repairs and improvements are approved following the arson at Governor’s Mansion in Harrisburg.

Coleman said he is proposing an “executive protection oversight board” that would “review and approve repairs to be made, to protect the governor and taxpayers at the same time in the event that the official residence would be temporarily uninhabitable.”

PREVIOUS COVERAGE | Taxpayers not paying for PA governor’s $1.1M private home security upgrades: treasurer

As described in the memo, the board would include three statewide row officers, representatives from four legislative caucuses and one nonvoting member appointed by the governor.

“The Ethics Act wasn’t followed, by the letter of the law,” he said. “There’s concerns all over the place, and ultimately right now, we have over $1 million of repairs that the state’s unable to pay,” Coleman said. He explained that the Commonwealth is looking at $1 million in repairs that have not been able to be paid by the Pennsylvania Treasury Department because the process fell short of the commonwealth procurement code.

The question of who should cover the upgrades remains unresolved, with state police saying the costs should be covered. The Shapiro Administration told CBS 21 News, The Governor’s Office and Pennsylvania State Police are unable to directly respond to legislation that we have yet to review.

State Treasurer Stacy Garrity cosigned the effort, saying:

Protecting the Governor and protecting taxpayers aren’t mutually exclusive. I applaud Sen. Coleman for taking the lead to find a solution that strikes that balance by ensuring that security decisions are backed by transparency and accountability.

Senate Democratic Leader Jay Costa criticized the proposal, saying:

While I have not seen the language of any legislation and therefore cannot comment on that directly, I continue to reject attempts to play ridiculous political games with the lives and safety of the Governor and his family. When politically motivated attacks threaten our Governor, law enforcement must be able to react swiftly and appropriately, without the interference of legislators. I continue to support efforts to ensure the safety of the Shapiros in their home, as recommended by the Pennsylvania State Police.

In response to the memo, Pennsylvania State Police Spokesperson, Sergeant Logan Brouse told CBS 21 News:

The Pennsylvania State Police is strongly opposed to any legislation that would limit law enforcement’s ability to act quickly to ensure the safety of Governor Shapiro and future governors. In this time of rising political violence, it is critical that the State Police are able to act efficiently and law enforcement recommendations remain in the hands of law enforcement, not elected officials.”

The memo also calls for the board to provide confidential reports and annual public summary reports. The memo had not yet been assigned a bill number before Senate floor consideration.