As one York center prepares to close after a license revocation, lawmakers question whether strict enforcement is pushing providers out.

YORK, Pa. — Lots of Love Daycare Center’s North Pershing Avenue location in York is set to close May 19 after a years-long legal battle ended with a judge upholding the state’s decision to revoke its license.

For owner Shannan Mosley, the closure marks more than the loss of a business location — it’s the disruption of routines for dozens of families and children.



This story continues below.



More in Local








Closure of York County daycare highlights broader Pa. debate over child care regulations




“I hurt for my staff. I hurt for my parents. I hurt for my kids the most,” Mosley said. “Because they’re used to routines. Some of these kids have been there since infancy.”

Mosley, who has spent 17 years in child care and operates six centers across Pennsylvania and Maryland, said this experience has felt unlike anything she has faced before.

“I’m used to [state licensing representatives] educating us if we’re doing something wrong. I’m used to them being a help,” Mosley said. “I never felt like I had to be on pins and needles when they walked in because we do things the correct way.”

Mosley argues many of the violations cited by the state were minor technical infractions that were quickly corrected — including a January citation for a trash can without a lid and another for missing handwashing signage.

“We’ve never had any harm come to children,” she said. “I think that’s why it’s so hurtful.”

Pennsylvania’s Department of Human Services, which oversees child care licensing, would not comment directly on Lots of Love’s case. But the department said it uses an inspection system called the Certification Inspection Instrument, or CII, to standardize how regulations are applied and enforced across facilities statewide.

In a statement to FOX43, spokesperson Brandon Cwalina said, “The Pennsylvania Department of Human Services takes the safety of all individuals in licensed child care facilities seriously.”

For the state, the system is designed to create consistency. For providers like Mosley, it can feel far more personal.

“I just don’t feel like it’s been fair for us,” she said.

The closure comes as child care providers across Pennsylvania continue warning lawmakers that mounting costs, staffing shortages and what some describe as overly rigid enforcement are making it harder to stay open.

Earlier this year, those concerns were front and center during a House Republican Policy Committee hearing in York County, where providers and lawmakers examined whether some regulations are effectively protecting children or creating unnecessary barriers.

“We have a very overregulated child care industry,” said State Rep. Kate Klunk (R-York County).

Klunk said lawmakers need to evaluate whether all regulations are truly serving families.

“We need to take a look at these regulations, figure out the ones that aren’t working for our providers and say, ‘Is this really keeping our kids safe?’” Klunk said. “Or is it impeding their ability to learn, thrive and grow?”

For now, Mosley said only the North Pershing Avenue site will close. Of the roughly 80 children currently enrolled there, she estimates only about 20 will be able to transition to another Lots of Love location, along with just a small number of staff members.

To help bridge that gap, Mosley said she has sold the North Pershing Avenue building to another child care provider, a move she hopes will restore access to child care for families left scrambling once the new owner’s licensing is approved.

Until then, many parents are being forced to search for alternatives in an already strained child care market.

Lots of Love is not the only York County provider facing scrutiny. York JCC’s Gan Rimon campus is also appealing its own license revocation, underscoring what many providers say is a broader statewide pattern.

As families look for stability, the closure of one York daycare is becoming part of a much larger question across Pennsylvania: When do small violations add up to accountability — and when do they become too much for providers to survive?