Pennsylvania’s battle over abortion rights is heading back to the state Supreme Court. The state’s Republican Attorney General Dave Sunday appealed a lower court’s ruling Tuesday that struck down the state’s ban on Medicaid coverage of abortions.

Sunday’s office did not respond to WESA’s request for comment Wednesday.

The case was originally brought by Pittsburgh’s Allegheny Reproductive Health Center and a half-dozen other abortion care providers in 2019. The providers argued that the Medicaid abortion ban discriminates against poor women seeking to terminate a pregnancy.

It has since taken an unusual journey through the courts. Sunday’s appeal marks the second time the high court has been tasked with reviewing a decision in the case. After the Commonwealth Court dismissed the case in 2021, the high court revived it in 2024, ruling the ban “presumptively unconstitutional.”

While the state’s Department of Human Services — which oversees Medicaid — is the defendant in the case, Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro has declined to defend the coverage ban. As a result, a unique hearing last year saw both DHS and abortion providers sitting on the same side of the courtroom without an attorney to defend the coverage ban.

Sunday, who was elected in 2024, has since taken up the matter, arguing that his office has a responsibility to defend Pennsylvania’s rule of law.

Abortion clinics are being represented in the case by the Philadelphia-based public interest law firm Women’s Law Project. A spokesperson decried the appeal Wednesday.

“The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has already called the Medicaid ban ‘presumptively unconstitutional,’” said Tara Murtha, director of impact and engagement at the Women’s Law Project. “This appeal is an expensive delay tactic that adds insult to injury. Pennsylvanians have suffered under this discriminatory law for decades and are now being forced to finance the delay of their own justice.”

Three Pennsylvania Supreme Court justices signaled a willingness to recognize abortion as a constitutionally-protected right when the court last reviewed the matter in 2024. In the high court’s majority opinion then, the justices described the choice of whether or not to give birth as “the most personal and consequential decision imaginable in the human experience.”

In a 4-3 decision last month, the Commonwealth Court ruled that the government cannot single out abortion for exclusion while funding comparable medical care. The ruling struck down the state’s ban, though it’s unclear if any Medicaid reimbursement for abortions began flowing before Sunday’s appeal this week.

Last month, the court said the coverage exclusion doesn’t advance any state interest to justify it and is in violation of equal protection provisions of the state constitution “beyond any genuine dispute of fact.”

Attorneys with the Women’s Law Project said Wednesday they remain confident in their case.

“The Attorney General has chosen to waste taxpayer dollars on trying to take reproductive rights away from Pennsylvanians,” said Susan Frietsche, the lead litigator on the case. “We look forward to once again arguing that reproductive choice belongs to the people, not the government.”