At a time when politics is bitterly divided, at least one issue seems capable of transcending the partisan divide: data centers.

Just ask southern Fayette County Republican state Rep. Charity Krupa, who cosponsored a bill to allow municipalities to set an 18-month moratorium on data center projects while updating their zoning codes.

The issue hits close to home for Krupa and her voters: A $1.7 billion project for a high-voltage electric line running through her rural district has been proposed in part to power the energy demand from data centers and improve the reliability of the state’s electric grid. And more broadly, critics worry a profusion of data centers will raise energy prices for consumers, deplete water resources and bring noise pollution

“It’s not a party-specific thing. In my area, you have far-left liberals and far-right MAGA conservatives … who think that there are serious environmental concerns,” Krupa told WESA.

Krupa is herself a vocal conservative, but she said she found common ground with Gov. Josh Shapiro, a Democrat, on at least one data center demand: that companies should bring their own energy source onto the grid so ratepayers don’t end up paying more.

“If they bring their own energy source, then there is a real opportunity for our natural gas industry to bloom again, and that would be a great economic boost,” Krupa said. But she said she believes “tight restrictions and stipulations with respect to water [need] to both make sure that the local water supply is not drained, and then also that it’s not contaminated.”

Last week Shapiro released finalized guidelines for what he says will “empower communities” during and after development. His “responsible infrastructure development” standards, or GRID plan, would persuade companies to invest in communities where they’re building, generate their own energy, and agree to environmental standards.

Krupa and several House Republicans also want to end a sales-tax incentive for data brokers and divert the estimated savings to decrease the state’s gas tax.

The data center industry is staunchly opposed to such efforts in Pennsylvania.

“A statewide moratorium on data centers would discourage investment and send a signal that Pennsylvania is closed for business,” said Dan Diorio, vice president of state policy for the Data Center Coalition, an industry advocacy group that represents companies such as Amazon, Google and Meta. He said the industry contributed $2 billion in state and local tax revenue and supported some 130,000 jobs in 2024.

“The data center industry remains committed to working with communities, local officials, and state leaders to ensure the continued responsible development of this critical industry while protecting families and businesses,” Diorio said.

Political cudgel

The politics around data centers appear to be in flux, with at least one poll showing opinion on the industry evenly divided, but with high levels of concern about their impact on electricity rates and water usage.

Some neighboring states that once offered incentives to centers are now seemingly having second thoughts. Last Wednesday, Ohio Gov. DeWine repealed a tax-credit program for data center development there. Meanwhile, legislation in New York seeks to pause development for up to three years.

And the ground is shifting in Pennsylvania’s own gubernatorial race as well.

Shapiro’s Republican gubernatorial challenger this fall, state Treasurer Stacy Garrity was once a booster of data center development.

Democrats note, for example, comments Garrity made during a talk radio show in August.: “[Pennsylvania] has 88 data centers. Ohio is kicking our butt — they have 192,” she said. “We could be doing so much more in that space.”

But she’s spoken more warily about the centers since.

Earlier this year, she said some rural parts of the state may be better suited for data development than others. At a January press luncheon in Harrisburg, she said proposed developments still require feedback from locals.

“You can’t just jam it down their throats,” she said at the time.

And when Shapiro unveiled his data center development standards, her campaign released a 3-minute video calling the move “damage control.”

“Josh Shapiro spent the last year rolling out the red carpet for massive data center development in Pennsylvania,” Garrity says in the spot. “He celebrated it, he promoted it, he said he was proud of it.

“But now, after communities across our Commonwealth have started raising serious concerns, he wants you to believe he is suddenly the one putting up guardrails,” she added.

“ Pennsylvania families should not have to pay the price for Josh Shapiro’s political cleanup operation, and that is why, as governor, I will pause data center development in Pennsylvania,” Garrity said.

Manuel Bonder, a spokesperson for Shapiro’s reelection campaign, says Garrity’s new stance is an about-face from last August.

“Stacy Garrity is a desperate politician – and her long record of supporting completely unregulated data center development makes it clear that she just can’t be trusted,” Bonder said.

Shapiro, he said, “has made it clear that while we compete for major projects and lead on innovation, we must set strict standards and ensure these projects benefit our communities and don’t impose costs on Pennsylvania.”

One of Garrity’s most vocal supporters, U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick says the state must seize the opportunity in the race to build data centers and boost the AI industry.

“ Pennsylvania can lead this revolution,” McCormick told reporters at a Harrisburg press lunch last month. “Pennsylvania is uniquely positioned to be at the forefront of this moment and to make sure that it benefits Pennsylvania in unique and profound ways.”