SCRANTON, LACKAWANNA CO. (WOLF) — Lackawanna County President Judge Thomas J. Gibbons has declined a request from county attorneys seeking clarification on his earlier order designating three county judges to serve on the Board of Elections for next week’s general election.
In a letter dated October 31, 2025, Judge Gibbons responded to county solicitors Donald J. Frederickson Jr. and Paul J. Walker, stating that his September 17 order “rather unambiguously says what it says” and that no clarification was necessary.
The correspondence came after county officials asked the court to revisit the issue amid continued disagreement over whether the county’s three commissioners or the appointed judges should oversee the November 4 election.
Judge Gibbons also rejected the attorneys’ invitation to discuss the matter further, writing that he was “disinclined to acquiesce” to their request.
In the letter, Gibbons appeared to question the attorneys’ claim that they were representing a majority of the commissioners, referencing recent media coverage of comments made by Commissioners Bill Gaughan and Chris Chermak.
“If the comments in the media from Commissioners Chermak and Gaughan are reported accurately,” Gibbons wrote, “the representation that you write on behalf of a majority of the Commissioners seems, at best, mistaken.”
The judge’s comments referenced a FOX56 report earlier this week detailing the commissioners’ divided positions on whether the election board should remain under judicial control or return to the commissioners.
The dispute stems from a September court order in which Judge Gibbons appointed Judges Terrence Nealon, Munley Bisignani-Moyle, and Vito Geroulo Ruggiero to the county Board of Elections following ongoing political and legal conflicts among the commissioners.
The general election is scheduled for Tuesday, November 4.
Comment with Bubbles
BE THE FIRST TO COMMENT
FOX56 has reached out to Solicitor Paul Walker for comment.