PITTSBURGH — The Pittsburgh Penguins have been blessed with several great general managers over the years, and many of them have been trade-happy by nature. Craig Patrick, Ray Shero and Jim Rutherford weren’t just good; they also rarely met a deal they didn’t like.
Kyle Dubas falls into the same category.
Dubas has executed 44 trades since taking control of the Penguins three years ago, more than one per month. He’s traded 42 players and acquired 42. He’s traded 20 draft picks and acquired 33.
Who’s next?
Here’s the biannual Penguins trade tiers list at a time when Dubas has acknowledged that trades are likely coming. We aren’t mentioning the unrestricted free agents such as Anthony Mantha and Noel Acciari for obvious reasons.

Barring an earth-shattering turn of events, Sidney Crosby is not being traded this offseason. (Charles LeClaire / Imagn Images)
The ‘Untouchable’ DivisionSidney Crosby
Let’s move on.
Evgeni Malkin
I suppose there’s a conceivable scenario where Malkin could be traded down the road. Say the Penguins have a terrible 2026-27 season, but Malkin still is playing at a high level come February. Would Dubas trade him if Malkin was OK with it? I could see it. But for the moment, obviously, he’s not going anywhere, and I find it wildly unlikely that he will ever play for a different team.
Sergei Murashov
Murashov hasn’t officially graduated to the NHL just yet, but he’s elevated to this portion of the list. The Penguins think he could be their No. 1 goaltender for the next decade-plus. That’s simply not the kind of player you trade.

Center Ben Kindel is exactly the type of young, talented player the Penguins need more of, not less. (Charles LeClaire / Imagn Images)
The ‘Almost Untouchable’ Division Ben Kindel
If a massive name becomes available and if the Penguins got involved, I could imagine Kindel being moved. But it probably isn’t going to happen. The Penguins love him. He’s almost certainly going to play a big role in their future.
Harrison Brunicke
Something truly strange would have to happen for Brunicke to be dealt. He’s their only top-tier prospect on the blue line and he’s right-handed, which makes him that much more valuable because Erik Karlsson is 36 and Kris Letang is 39.
Egor Chinakhov
They didn’t give up a couple of picks for him and watch him go on a 40-goal pace in the second half of the season to trade him.

Erik Karlsson regained his form last season, so he seems unlikely to be traded. Still, never say never. (Michael Reaves / Getty Images)
The ‘Unlikely’ DivisionErik Karlsson
If the Penguins want to be good in the 2026-27 season — and I believe this is the goal — then trading Karlsson makes no sense. He was their best player last season and was magical in the second half. So, I expect him to stay. But in this case, everyone has a price.
Rutger McGroarty
The Penguins have high hopes for him despite his so-so season. But I can’t say he’s unmovable. Still, there would have to be something serious coming back to Pittsburgh because McGroarty is still clearly one of the best Penguins prospects.
Joel Blomqvist
I’m guessing the young goaltender will remain in the organization and receive a heavy workload in Wilkes-Barre next season. At that point, he’s either great insurance if Murashov falters, a potential mate with Murashov at the NHL level, or attractive trade bait.

Bill Zonnon isn’t quite ready for prime time yet, but the Penguins think highly of him. (Bruce Bennett / Getty Images)
The ‘Only In a Blockbuster’ DivisionBill Zonnon
The Penguins really, really like him. He’ll probably spend most of next season in Wilkes-Barre before an inevitable promotion to the NHL, either late next season or the following campaign. He’d only be traded in a huge deal.
Will Horcoff
I’d essentially say the same of Horcoff. Despite his goal-scoring binge at Michigan last season, the Penguins think he’s a couple of years away from being NHL-ready. But that doesn’t mean they don’t like him. They do.
Parker Wotherspoon
Wotherspoon gives the Penguins immense value. He’s a legitimate, top-four defenseman making $1 million annually for another season. Why would you trade him? Good question! You probably wouldn’t, unless someone offered something stupid in return.

Rickard Rakell is valuable to the Penguins, but he’s also valuable in a trade to another team. He could be dealt, but the price will not be cheap. (Charles LeClaire / Imagn Images)
The ‘It Might Be Time’ DivisionRickard Rakell
For the right price, he’s available. Dubas and the coaching staff love Rakell. So does everyone in the locker room. He’s a very good player who has been outstanding in each of the past two seasons. With two years remaining on his contract, he brings significant value with a $5 million cap hit. But he’s 33, and the Penguins badly want to find impactful younger players. He’s the kind of player who could theoretically fetch that. He’s very much available but won’t be given away on the cheap.
Bryan Rust
Rust is essentially in the same boat. He’s one of the more beloved teammates in franchise history and is pretty much good for an automatic 25 to 30 goals a season. Dubas doesn’t want to trade him, but contending teams have wanted Rust for years and still do. The market stinks. If one team gets really ravenous for Rust and offers a significant package, Dubas will pull the trigger.

Sam Girard, who came over from the Avalanche last season in the Brett Kulak trade, hasn’t fully fit in with the Penguins. (Charles LeClaire / Imagn Images)
The ‘It Could Happen’ DivisionSam Girard
It wouldn’t shock me if Girard is dealt this summer. He never fit in with the Penguins’ playing style. I don’t know that his value is all that high at the moment, but if Dubas wants to reshape his blue line, this could happen.
Tommy Novak
The organization likes him a lot. But there are three things to consider: Novak has only one year remaining on his deal, he’s going to be 30 in April and, while he’s a perfectly solid player, he’s the weak link in the top six. If the Penguins want to improve their team this summer, second-line center would be an intriguing place to start. He was under-the-radar good last season, but he’s not great. If the Penguins land a top-six player this summer in a trade, he’d be a logical piece of any return.
2026 first-round pick
Why would they trade this pick? Here’s why: They would love to move up in the draft, and they’d probably have to give up this pick to do it.
Other draft picks
I expect plenty of wheeling and dealing up and down the draft from Dubas.

Blake Lizotte is more important to the Penguins as a player than a trade chip. (Charles LeClaire / Imagn Images)
The ‘What’s The Point’ DivisionBlake Lizotte
The Penguins gave him a three-year deal for a reason. They’re a better team when he’s healthy and in the lineup.
Connor Dewar
He’s valuable to the Penguins and doesn’t have a ton of trade value. So, what’s the point?
Elmer Söderblom
The Penguins wouldn’t just give him away. He found his footing in Pittsburgh late last season.
Avery Hayes
He doesn’t have much in the way of trade value, but he could be on the fourth line to start next season.
Artūrs Šilovs
I expect he’ll receive a two-year deal and will be goalie 1A behind Murashov next season.
Justin Brazeau
He had a great start and a bad finish to his season. He doesn’t make much money. I’m not sure where he fits moving forward, but he’s not a terrible piece to have around.

It would be difficult to unload Kris Letang’s contract, but it could happen. (Steph Chambers / Getty Images)
The ‘We Can Talk’ DivisionKris Letang
I don’t expect Letang to be traded, but the Penguins aren’t against it. The question is whether anyone wants him. If a team acquired Letang, they’d be getting him for two years at $6.1 million per year. Would anyone give him that on the open market, given his recent performance, age and health history? I doubt it very much.

Ryan Graves’ contract runs for three more seasons at $4.5 million per season. (Michael Reaves / Getty Images)
The ‘He’s All Yours’ DivisionRyan Graves
Three more years to go.