The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has ruled that skill games are illegal under Pennsylvania’s current Crimes Code and Gaming Act.
In the decision, Justice David Wecht writes that skill games are slot machines, “several times over” and that the Commonwealth Court’s decision that “skill games fall into a legal gray area” was “deeply flawed and incorrect.”
Even though they have now been deemed illegal, the Court did issue a 120-day stay order and as Pennsylvania House Gaming Oversight Committee Chairman Pat Harkins explained to Philip Ward, the games may not be going away just yet.
“If my committee does not do anything they would ultimately become illegal machines that would have to be removed from the system but I do anticipate that we will do something with them,” Harkins said.
“Whatever we do it has to have parity and they have to be taxed at the same amount the casinos are taxed at, otherwise we will go right back into another court case,” Harkins said.
Pace-O-Matic, reacting to the ruling, wrote in a statement:
“We are disappointed with the decision by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court and strongly believe it does not accurately reflect the facts presented – notably, the same facts that led to a string of lower court rulings affirming the legality of our skill games, including a unanimous Commonwealth Court ruling. Sadly, this opinion will have far-reaching consequences, with more than 10,000 Pennsylvania small businesses and fraternal clubs becoming the real victims. They are now potentially left facing an impossible choice: cease operating these games and lose an important source of revenue, or endure a legislative solution that could bring excessive regulation and crippling taxation, which will force them to cease operating these games and lose an important source of revenue. The better option is for the legislature to support a commonsense piece of legislation that will tax and regulate skill games fairly, like the bipartisan bills sponsored by Senator Yaw (SB 1079) and Representative Burgos (HB 2213).
“However, we do agree with the court that ‘determining and manifesting the public policy of Pennsylvania is the prerogative of the legislative branch of our government,’ and in accordance with the court-ordered 120-day stay of action, we will continue work with lawmakers toward a legislative solution for skill games. Our number one priority continues to be supporting our small business and nonprofit partners across the commonwealth. Pace-O-Matic will always abide by the rule of law.”