As the Pittsburgh Pirates flirt with slipping out of contention, the club is grappling with one of its major ongoing weak spots: the bullpen.

To be sure, at times, the Pirates’ offense has been quiet while the starters haven’t performed to their full potential. But over the course of the year, the bullpen has struggled to hit its stride as a collective unit.

Through Tuesday, the Pirates have suffered 15 blown saves, tied for fourth-most in baseball.

Pirates relievers in save situations have converted just 16 of 31 opportunities (51.6%), a devastatingly low clip for a club lingering around .500 in a highly competitive NL Central division.

Overall, the Pirates (37-37) rank 20th in MLB in bullpen ERA (4.44) and 22nd in WHIP (1.40).

It couldn’t be said that general manager Ben Cherington hasn’t shuffled the deck internally with the major- and minor-league pieces at his disposal.

But with Pirates potentially in need of outside help, here are some options Cherington could consider:

Note: All contractual information is courtesy of Spotrac.

Aroldis Chapman

Team: Boston Red Sox

Age: 38

Throws: Left-handed

2026 stats: 0-1, 0.44 ERA, 14 saves

Contract: $13 million in 2026; $13 million mutual option in 2027

Pirates fans should be more than familiar with Aroldis Chapman, the veteran flamethrowing lefty who spent 2024 in Pittsburgh on a one-year deal.

That season, Chapman struggled at times with command, but went 5-5 with a 3.79 ERA in 68 games, serving primarily as setup man.

Following 2024, the Pirates let Chapman walk and he landed with the Red Sox, where in 2025 he was an All-Star for the first time since 2015, having gone 5-3 with a 1.17 ERA and 32 saves over 61 1/3 frames, striking out 85 with just 15 walks.

So far this year, Chapman has continued to pitch at an all-star level, again serving as Boston’s closer.

Only problem is, the Red Sox are last in the AL East and appear to be well out of contention.

That should make Chapman an enticing trade chip.

On top of fetching a significant return package, Chapman’s $13 million salary, as well as a $13 mutual option for 2027, will be an obvious consideration for the Pirates.

If Chapman did return to Pittsburgh, it’d likely spark some alterations to the club’s current bullpen deployment.

Gregory Soto’s (4-1, 3.16 ERA, 11 saves) role as the closer could be disrupted, but Soto, in Year 1 with the Pirates, hadn’t been utilized as a closer since 2022 with the Tigers until being slotted into that role this season.

In theory, a reversion back to the role (pitching the seventh or eighth inning) he was performing in 2023, 2024 and 2025 wouldn’t be too far-fetched, if Soto is willing to do it.

In conclusion, whether the Pirates get him or not, Chapman will be one of the hottest names on the trade market this cycle.

Antonio Senzatela

Team: Colorado Rockies

Age: 31

Throws: Right-handed

2026 Stats: 6-0, 2.29 ERA

Contract: $12 million in 2026, $14 million club option in 2027

Antonio Senzatela is having a superb season for the hapless Rockies, with a 1.04 WHIP, 32 strikeouts and 12 walks through 39 1/3 innings.

This season, he is in the closing stages of a five-year, $50.5 million deal with a club option for 2027.

Like Chapman, he’s playing for a club that is well out of contention and could be looking to offload unnecessary payroll, but the Pirates taking on that kind of salary and parting with assets could be a bridge too far for Cherington.

A 10-year MLB veteran who’s played his entire career in Colorado, Senzatela has been versatile this season, pitching some bulk relief and being a player manager Warren Schaeffer entrusts to toss multiple innings regularly.

Nine of his 21 outings have been in the eighth inning or later.

A reliable option for the seventh or eighth, plus a pitcher who can eat multiple innings, is a major need for the Pirates.

If they are indeed on the market for proven bullpen help, Senzatela is a name to monitor.

Kyle Finnegan

Team: Detroit Tigers

Age: 34

Throws: Right-handed

2026 stats: 2-0, 1.87 ERA

Contract: $8.75 million in 2026, $8 million in 2027, $10 million in 2028

As could be said of the aforementioned trade options, Finnegan’s acquisition would come with a substantial payroll commitment beyond this year.

At 34, Finnegan is far from a spring chicken, yet the seven-year veteran who was an All-Star closer for the Nationals in 2024 is having a solid year.

Through 32 appearances and 33 2/3 innings, Finnegan has allowed only seven earned runs.

But is he riding a wave of luck that is bound to come crashing down?

While runs have infrequently come around to score on Finnegan, on-base traffic has been a regularity, as he owns a WHIP of 1.49 and has walked 22 batters to 21 strikeouts.

This year in Detroit, the Tigers have pitched him mainly in the seventh and eighth innings.

Over parts of six years with Washington, Finnegan recorded 108 saves and has 113 for his career.

Other options

Plenty of other relief pitching options will be on the table for Cherington, and the Pirates general manager, if he is so inclined, can do as deep of a dive as he wants in searching for viable help.

Spotrac currently lists players such as Miami’s Pete Fairbanks, St. Louis’ JoJo Romero and several Diamondbacks pitchers like Ryan Thompson, Kevin Ginkel, Taylor Clarke and Paul Sewald as relief pitcher trade candidates.

From the Pirates’ perspective, the problematic similarity with those options is that they all play for contenders.

On June 17, the Marlins (36-38) are competing for a wild-card berth, as are the Diamondbacks (37-36).

Regarding Romero, it seems unfathomable that St. Louis would ship any sort of asset to a division rival near it in the standings.

Thus, if Cherington wants to acquire help now, he may be forced to limit his scope to clubs already out of contention.

Who will emerge in that prospective search, and what the Pirates have to pay in dollars and return pieces to get them, remains to be seen.