The rules are the rules because they have been codified and agreed to. Sometimes that’s not convenient, but it’s true nonetheless.
The United States didn’t end Prohibition by pretending the 18th Amendment no longer mattered. It ended it by ratifying the 21st Amendment, repealing the national ban on alcohol through the same constitutional process that had created it.
The country changed its mind. It then collectively agreed to new rules.
Every municipality is littered with the remnants of laws that were once deemed important but later abandoned without being repealed — superseded by new ways of doing things while the bones of the old ways remained to confuse and complicate until they were forgotten.
That’s what happens when the rules are just stuck on a shelf instead of being changed.
Governments evolve. Laws change. Charters are amended. Courts reinterpret statutes. The rules of government are meant to be rewritten when they no longer serve the public.
But there is always a way to do it.
This week, Pittsburgh promoted Cmdr. Lori McCartney to assistant chief even though she lives outside the city, this despite language in the home rule charter requiring nonunion police personnel to reside in Pittsburgh. The administration argues that changes in state law and labor decisions effectively rendered that requirement obsolete.
Maybe so. That doesn’t mean ignoring the requirement is the way to handle the situation.
This is not about McCartney. She accepted a promotion offered by the city. There is no reason to believe she did anything wrong. It is not on an employee to be a check on the system that employs her.
It is about the people who made that promotion and the process they chose to follow.
If city leaders believe Pittsburgh’s residency requirement for police leadership is outdated, superseded or simply bad policy, they may have a good argument. But there is a proper way to address that. It isn’t by acting as though the charter already has changed.
There is something particularly noteworthy about this involving the police bureau. Police officers spend every day enforcing laws that many people dislike or oppose. The authority to do that depends on public confidence that government follows the law, too.
“How is it good for morale to say the rules apply to this person but not to this other?” said Councilwoman Kim Salinetro, D-West End.
The short answer, whether you are talking about other officers or residents: It isn’t.
“You’re going every which way to skirt the law,” said Fraternal Order of Police Fort Pitt Lodge 1 president Robert Swartzwelder.
And skirting it isn’t necessary.
Changing the home rule charter is not impossible. It is barely difficult. It simply requires putting the question before the people for a vote. That’s a step that happens all the time. Pittsburghers voted on a question about public notices in the May primary. Allegheny County is putting two questions on the ballot in November.
Of course, there is always the possibility the people wouldn’t agree. They might want their officials to continue to be their neighbors.
If city leaders believe a provision no longer serves Pittsburgh, they should make that case to the voters and ask them to change it. What government should not do is proceed as though the law has already been rewritten.
Featured Local Businesses