David Mitchell, who was put on leave in 2022, is accused of the same phony police log activity that nabbed two other former officers years ago

SCRANTON, Pa. — A former Scranton police officer who collected tens of thousands of dollars during years of paid suspension for alleged overtime theft was charged Wednesday by state agents with a misdemeanor.

David Mitchell, of Scranton, was ordered to appear Dec. 9 before Magisterial District Judge Alyce Hailstone Farrell for a preliminary hearing on a charge of theft by deception.

Mitchell was one of three former city police officers who submitted paperwork fraudulently claiming they worked extra-duty shifts at low-income city housing units at the beginning of the decade,  the state Attorney General’s Office said.

The others, Jeff Vaughn and Paul Helring, were charged in federal court in 2022 and accused of stealing thousands of dollars by submitting paperwork for payment for hundreds of overtime they never worked.

Helring, who was the police union president, took nearly $18,000 for 526 hours of non-existent work, federal authorities disclosed in court.

They were both sentenced to six months behind bars.

Mitchell, by comparison, is accused of stealing far less. Misdemeanor thefts are typically charged when the amount falls under $2,000.

According to a criminal complaint, Mitchell did not leave his home for seven four-hour extra-duty shifts between February 2022 and May 2022. That meant Mitchell would have collected approximately $950 for hours he did not work, according to the complaint. 

Investigators surveilling Mitchell also noted he provided false logs for 13 other shifts between January 2022 and May 2022, during which he left his home, but only for a short while.

Attempts to reach Mitchell for comment Wednesday were unsuccessful. It was not clear from court filings if he has an attorney.

In an interview with federal investigators in May 2022, Mitchell admitted he did not always actively patrol the complexes. 

“Instead, Mitchell told investigators that he stayed home and waited for a call to come over the radio at which point he claims he would respond to the incident,” authorities wrote in an affidavit. “Mitchell claimed that he was never told he had to report to the housing complexes in person and actively patrol, notwithstanding this was the intent of the grant paid duty.”

An interview with another detective who sometimes worked with Mitchell contradicted him. When they had a scheduled shift, they met beforehand and patrolled together. Mitchell’s logs also included notes he “patrolled complex” and “maintained traffic” while he was not actually present, investigators said.

“Your affiant believes that Mitchell knowingly and intentionally failed to patrol the Housing Projects but continued to collect the overtime,” agents wrote.

Mitchell was placed on paid suspension on May 17, 2022, the same day federal agents stopped by his house for an interview.

Under suspicion and under investigation — but uncharged — he remained on suspension and drawing a paycheck.

In October 2024, nearly 2½ years after Mitchell was first put on leave, a city spokesperson confirmed to Newswatch 16 that Mitchell remained suspended.

The spokesperson, Christopher Hughes, said at the time Mitchell was paid “$72,084.20 in gross wages this year.” 

That amount, however, does not include the funds disbursed in 2023 and the latter half of 2022. Attempts to determine the full amount the city paid Mitchell were not immediately successful Tuesday. It was also unclear if the city, now that Mitchell had been charged, had any recourse to recoup those funds. 

Efforts to reach Police Chief Tom Carrol and Mayor Paige Cognetti were unsuccessful.

The state attorney general’s office also did not respond to an email seeking clarification as to why they did not charge Mitchell until years after Vaughan and Helring faced prosecution. The most recent investigative activity on the case was in November 2024, when agents interviewed the detective who once patrolled with Mitchell, according to the affidavit.

Meanwhile, after a long suspension, Mitchell’s time with the city police department quietly ended sometime between October last year and May.

Minutes from a Scranton Police Pension Commission meeting in May show that Mitchell applied for a length-of-service pension. 

The request caused ripple of concern among the pension board.

One member noted that Mitchell, “is under federal investigation and does not want the board to go into a situation like that, that occurred with Paul Helring,” according to the minutes.

Helring successfully sought a disability pension before he was federally charged and the board took legal action to revoke his payments.

The board went into an executive session to discuss “personnel” and then, emerging from the off-the-record session, held a vote and approved Mitchell’s request. 

Hughes confirmed the board approved Mitchell’s pension but said that Mitchell, who is 47-years-old, could not start collecting payments until he turns 55.

The board’s approval, according to the minutes, also came with a noted caveat: Mitchell’s pension would come back under review in the future Mitchell found himself faced with legal trouble.