This is WESA Arts, a weekly newsletter by Bill O’Driscoll providing in-depth reporting about the Pittsburgh area art scene. Sign up here to get it every Wednesday afternoon.

If you’re in Squirrel Hill this Saturday and pass by Jerry’s Records, you might see folks hurling 45 rpm records across the sidewalk like Frisbees.

They’ll be aiming for a bucket. But rest assured, it’s one of the few times you’ll catch anyone at Jerry’s throwing records away.

The store, which this weekend celebrates a half-century since its late namesake founder began selling used vinyl, has an estimated 1 million records on site, some nearly 80 years old. And the vast majority of the time, it’s focused on coddling those discs and chaperoning them to the turntables of customers who might like anything from Elvis and Beethoven to Roberta Flack, Cannonball Adderly, Metallica, Tone Loc or “24 Popular Irish Dance Favorites.”

Founder Jerry Weber retired in 2017 and died five years later. But along with servicing the healthy local appetite for classic and rare LPs and more, the massive store on Murray Avenue remains as good as anyone this side of the Steelers at luring visitors to town.

“Honestly, on a daily basis, there’s people from out of town, whether they’re from somewhere else in the U.S. or from other countries,” says Chris Grauzer, who took over the store from Weber. “We get people from Europe, we get people from South America, you name it. … Buyers from the U.K. who come here just to shop.”

DJs, at least the kind who still spin vinyl, have long dug Jerry’s too.

“Every time I have an out-of-town visitor who is a music fan, I take them to Jerry’s,” says WYEP director of creative services Brian Siewiorek, who hosts the all-vinyl show The Grooves. “It used to be my first stop on Sunday-morning errands, and most times Jerry himself was sitting behind the counter. Now, when I look through my records and come across an old Jerry’s price tag (usually $3 or $7) or one of their ‘Exceptionally Clean’ stickers, it puts a smile on my face. Pittsburgh has been so fortunate to have such a place for the last 50 years.”

Weber was a mail carrier who in 1976 joined fellow record collector Jim Petruzzi to open the Record Graveyard, in Oakland. A few years later, Weber split off to launch Garbage Records, later renamed Jerry’s. The shop relocated to its current home, a former car dealership, in 1994.

The 10,000-square-foot main store is jam-packed with LPs, its aisles wide enough to slip by fellow browsers. The section reserved for jazz, country and gospel alone is as large as many whole used record shops. Jerry’s might in fact be, as Weber used to claim, the biggest store in the nation dedicated to used vinyl.

Most of the LPs, says Grauzer, come either from individuals scaling down or from the families of the departed. The lots range into the thousands of individual records. And despite the remarkable resurgence of new vinyl — some 47 million EPs and LPs were sold in 2025, nearly 50 times more than in ’06 — most of Jerry’s stock dates from the late ’80s or earlier.

For non-aficionados in the digital age, the question of who’s still buying mechanically engraved PVC platters might seem mysterious.

Some are collectors like Grauzer was 20 years ago, when he stopped by daily just to see what was new. (It was a habit that turned into a part-time and then a full-time job.)

Others are bulk buyers from places as distant as Hong Kong and Japan, who Grauzer says purchase “pallets of stuff” to satisfy audiophile cravings back home for jazz and classical, though he adds that market has shrunk as shipping costs have risen.

And more buyers these days, says Grauzer, are young.

“I mean, we’re talking even 18 to 30-year-olds,” he says.

Favorite buys have not changed much: rock, soul and jazz predominate, and the appeal of Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelin seems timeless. But Grauzer thinks vinyl allure is more than just the appeal of media you can hold in your hand.

“I think young people are also getting sick of streaming things,” he says. Streaming playlists, he says, are the enemy of intentional listening.

“It’s people who are serious listeners of music,” he adds. “They want to actually listen to the music, not have it on in the background.”

The faithful will gather this weekend. From Friday, Aug. 28, through Sunday, Aug. 30, comes one of Jerry’s semi-annual Dollar Sales, with 20,000 LPs, CDs, DVDs and more on offer for $1 each. (Non-vinyl media are sold in Jerry’s Future Zone annex.)

Saturday’s 50th-anniversary celebration, meanwhile, features a storewide 15% off sale, food, DJ sets by Buscrates, and “carnival games” including that 45 rpm record toss, with store credit as the prize.

And don’t fret about those singles people are flinging. Grauzer assures they are completely unplayable.