The outside of Isla Paraiso Restaurant in Scranton Wednesday, September 2, 2026. (SEAN MCKEAG / STAFF PHOTOGRAPHER)
A West Side business deemed a nuisance by Lackawanna County District Attorney Brian Gallagher, can remain in business but under strict operating restrictions finalized at a hearing on Thursday.
Last week, Gallagher petitioned the Court to close down the Isla Paraiso Restaurant, 1001 S. Main Ave., after multiple incidences of fighting and concluding with gunfire, a foot chase and an arrest early on Aug. 30. But, even Gallagher and complaining neighbors acknowledged there had been no problems with the business before June, when it began opening as a nightclub several days a week.
It’s a partial win for both sides. The restaurant agreed to serving only food, not alcohol, and only until 10 p.m. at hearing before Lackawanna County Judge Michael Barresse. The liquor license will be put on hold for now, and the restaurant will not be able to serve liquor or operate as a BYOB establishment.
Following finalization of the order memorializing the agreement, owner Franchesca Franco said she was pleased with the agreement which allowed the business to reopen and serve the community.
The business which temporarily closed after Gallagher’s original petition on Sept. 1, is slated to remain closed until Sept. 24, with parties allowed to go inside the building to prepare to reopen.
The agreement will be valid for one year.