The owner of two small properties in the 600 block of Madison Avenue in Scranton that recently lost their tax-exempt statuses is suing to restore them or get their new tax assessments reduced.

Simrell Park Association, which owns the properties at 627 Madison Ave. and 629-631 Madison Ave. claims they meet all criteria required for tax-exempt statuses, according to a pair of separate, but similar, tax-appeal lawsuits filed Sept. 22 against the Lackawanna County Board of Assessment Appeals. One lawsuit involves 627 Madison Ave., which is a small yard, while the other suit involves 629-631 Madison Ave., which contains a driveway.

The appeal lawsuits are a response to recent successful “reverse exemption appeals” by the city and Scranton School District that resulted in the two properties having their tax-exempt statuses removed and put onto the tax rolls for next year.

In July, the city and SSD jointly filed the reverse appeals, including two each against Simrell Park Association (627 Madison Ave. and 629-631 Madison Ave.), Milk Saving Starving Children (a restaurant property at 801 N. Washington Ave. and a vacant parcel at 400 Gibson St.), and 20th Ward Social and Athletic Club (2028 Pittston Ave. and an undeveloped property at Birney Avenue and Gibbons Street); and one against Scranton Liederkranz Co. (508 Lackawanna Ave.).

The city reached a settlement with Milk Saving Staving Children to put it on the tax rolls in 2027, and the county assessment board on Aug. 27 determined the other three entities do not qualify for property tax exemptions and should be reclassified as taxable, effective in 2027.

The reverse appeals stemmed from the city’s first tax-exemption-verification review launched in December of 2023. This initiative reviews and verifies the tax-exempt status of nonprofit and government-owned properties by conducting what’s known as a HUP test. At that time, in 2023, the city had 1,622 tax-exempt properties that accounted for nearly 37%, or about $220 million, of Scranton’s $598 million total assessed property value. Nearly 6% of Scranton’s 27,000-plus parcels were off the tax rolls.

The HUP test, which gets its name from a landmark 1985 state Supreme Court decision in Hospital Utilization Project v. Commonwealth, established five prongs an organization must meet to qualify as a tax-exempt charity under the state constitution. The test holds that to be considered a purely public charity, the entity seeking a tax exemption must advance a charitable purpose, donate or render gratuitously a substantial portion of its services, benefit a substantial and indefinite class of people who are legitimate subjects of charity, relieve the government of some of its burden and operate entirely free from profit motive.

The county assessment board over the past year or so twice issued letters to all of the nonprofits in the city to verify their tax-exempt statuses. Many responded and many did not. The four nonprofits that were challenged had not responded and became the first entities that faced appeal challenges from the city and school district contending none met the HUP test for tax-exemption.

But the Simrell Park Association tax-appeal lawsuits claim the two Simrell properties meet all HUP test requirements for tax exemption. Prepared by attorney Matthew Barrett of Barrett Law LLC of Scranton, the Simrell lawsuits also claim Simrell Park Association was not given notices of the city and school district reverse challenges or the board’s hearings.

The lawsuit claims the assessment board erred and seeks to have both Simrell properties reclassified as tax-exempt or, alternatively, have their new assessments reduced. The appeal lawsuits claim the new assessments are based on erroneous determinations of fair market values and substantially higher than comparable properties.

Assessments for 2027 valued 627 Madison Ave.’s land at $46,250 and improvements at $1,470; and valued 629-631 Madison Ave.’s land at $54,100 and improvements at $4,910.

The reverse exemption challenges followed the first countywide reassessment in Lackawanna County since 1968 that was completed last year and that took effect this year.

Based on revised 2026 assessments and city and school district millage rates of 6.35 and 9.56, respectively, the city estimated the four successful reverse tax challenges will produce a total of $31,332 in tax revenue to the two governing bodies in 2027, or $12,507 to the city and $18,825 to the school district. They did not calculate county taxes to be collected, because the county was not a party to the original tax-exempt challenge.

A retroactive clawback of taxes not paid in prior years also is not possible; and the city and school district might pursue other, similar challenges of nonprofit statuses, officials have said.