
TUNKHANNOCK — The verdict is in. Phillip D. Walters is a two-time convicted murderer
A jury convicted Walters of first-degree murder, third-degree murder, strangulation and abuse of a corpse on Tuesday following a seven-day trial in Wyoming County Court.
Walters, 39, killed his girlfriend, Haley Lorenzen, at his Falls Twp. home on Dec. 30, 2018, then dumped her body from the Falls Bridge into the Susquehanna River, prosecutors alleged.
He had been convicted in October 2020 and sentenced to life in prison without possibility of parole, but his lawyers appealed and the state Supreme Court vacated his conviction and ordered him to stand trial again.
No date was set for Walters’ sentencing after Senior Judge Thomas A. James read the verdict and polled the jury. Walters will be returned to state prison.
“He got what he deserved,” said Deanna Hills, Lorenzen’s mother, during a brief press conference outside the county courthouse Tuesday afternoon.
“No family should have to go through this once, let alone twice,” said Hills, who traveled from her home in Oregon to testify at the trial.
District Attorney Joe Peters, who led the prosecution team, thanked the family and First Assistant District Attorney Deborah Albert-Heise, as well as the investigators, police officers and witnesses who testified.
In closing arguments Tuesday morning, lead defense attorney Bernard Brown presented the theory that Gabel Bell — a prosecution witness who received immunity from prosecution in exchange for her testimony against Walters — might have murdered Lorenzen.
Bell testified that she helped Walters remove Lorenzen’s lifeless body from his home and dump the body into the river.
Peters told the jury the prosecution had made its case and presented enough evidence to convict Walters, apart from Bell’s testimony.
The prosecution presented that evidence over the course of five trial days, starting on Sept. 22 and concluding Monday, Sept. 28.
Bell testified for five hours on Thursday, describing her intimate relationship with Walters and her anguish when she heard that Lorenzen had moved from her Oregon home to live with Walters in early November 2018.
Hills and Lorenzen’s father, Ralph Lorenzen, provided emotional testimony in which they described Lorenzen as a sweet young woman who loved children and Christmas.
Numerous investigators and expert witnesses testified as the prosecution presented its case.