Editor’s note: We are publishing a series of fact-checks of advertisements in the Pennsylvania 8th Congressional District race between incumbent Republican Congressman Rob Bresnahan of Dallas Twp. and Democratic challenger, Scranton Mayor Paige Cognetti. The election is key for both major parties’ hopes of holding a House majority the next two years.
This 30-second ad is paid for by the Congressional Leadership Fund, a super PAC that works to elect Republicans to the U.S. House of Representatives. It can raise and spend unlimited amounts of money on elections, but cannot give money directly to candidates or their official campaigns. As such, the ad was not authorized by any candidate or committee.
The ad begins with black-and-white clips of Cognetti speaking, seen in front of a pink background with the U.S. Capitol pictured. The narrator opens with a statement — “Paige Cognetti knows,” she says. — before a clip of Cognetti saying, “We have really high taxes in this city.” Stacks of cash start piling up behind her as a clip of Cognetti talking about not being able to promise lower taxes, despite the fact she would “love to” do so.
A letter graphic appears next as hearts pop up on screen, with the words “Love Letter…Paige Cognetti…Love For Power” written on it. As the letter opens, the words, “Raised property taxes” appears, and Cognetti is again seen announcing a budget proposal that would include a 3.5% property tax increase.
More hearts appear, as do the words “Paige Cognetti: Higher Taxes Every Year.” The final graphic reads, “Paige Cognetti…Loves Getting Ahead…At Your Expense” as scenes from the Capitol air in the background.
Key claim
“She wants higher taxes, and higher office. Because Paige Cognetti loves moving up, no matter the cost.”
Is it factual?
The ad misrepresents, in a few ways, Cognetti’s record as Scranton’s mayor when it comes to tax hikes.
The clip in which Cognetti states that Scranton’s taxes are “really high” is undated and unsourced, making it challenging to put into context. However, it is also statistically true. For example in 2019, the year before Cognetti took office, every municipality bordering Scranton capped its earned income tax rate at 1%, the state standard. Because Scranton was still considered financially distressed under Act 47 at the time, it was legally allowed to charge a 3.4% rate. Similarly, Scranton charged the maximum allowable local services tax, $156, for anyone working inside city limits that year.
Later that same year, Cognetti created a group to examine better ways to address the burden on taxpayers created by the tax structure.
Property taxes indeed were raised in Scranton during the Cognetti administration, as the city climbed out of distressed status for the first time in 30 years. In late 2022, City Council voted 3-2 to adopt Cognetti’s 2023 spending plan that included a 2% hike in property taxes. In 2023, it was the same story: A 3-2 council vote to adopt a 2024 budget that included another 2% tax increase.
Cognetti’s initial budget proposals both of those years came with higher proposed tax increases; 3% in 2023 and 3.5% in 2024. Both years, Cognetti made cuts that trimmed to the 2% rates that earned council approval.
The graphic in the ad that read “Paige Cognetti: Higher Taxes Every Year” is false. Four of the six budgets passed during Cognetti’s tenure — in 2021, 2022, 2025 and 2026 — did not include municipal tax increases.