ARCHBALD — Data center opponents challenged Tuesday whether changing conceptual plans for a proposed power plant on Eynon Jermyn Road is enough to prove the project meets the borough’s requirements for protecting public health and safety — continuing a months-long standoff between Stop Archbald Data Centers and Essential Energy LLC.
“You are here to testify to this borough council that despite the fact that it is a conceptual design, it can be designed, constructed and operated in a safe way?” asked attorney Justin Richards, who represents residents challenging proposed data centers in Archbald.
“There is a way that we can do this,” replied KCI Technologies Technical Lead of Power Generation Andrew Markle, testifying on behalf of Essential Energy. “We can do this — I’m not telling you how we’re going to do it — I’m saying that we can do this.”
Borough council held its sixth conditional-use hearing to consider Essential Energy’s March 12 application for a 400-megawatt natural gas power plant on Eynon Jermyn Road. About 70 residents clustered throughout the Valley View High School auditorium, occasionally applauding or jeering during the three-hour hearing.

Andrew Markle, left, technical lead of power generation for KCI Technologies of Mechanicsburg, and Essential Energy attorney Frank Hoegen listen to a question from Stop Archbald Data Centers attorney Justin Richards at an Essential Energy hearing at Valley View High School on Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2026. (CHAD SEBRING/STAFF PHOTO)

Members of Archbald Borough Council Larry Marchetti, left, Erin Owen, center and Madonna Munley listen to testimony at an Essential Energy hearing at Valley View High School on Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2026. (CHAD SEBRING/STAFF PHOTO)
Show Caption
1 of 2
Andrew Markle, left, technical lead of power generation for KCI Technologies of Mechanicsburg, and Essential Energy attorney Frank Hoegen listen to a question from Stop Archbald Data Centers attorney Justin Richards at an Essential Energy hearing at Valley View High School on Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2026. (CHAD SEBRING/STAFF PHOTO)
There are 51 data centers proposed in Archbald across six projects, though more are likely on the way. Essential Energy is a firm tied to Kriger Construction Inc. of Archbald and its executive leadership — President Jim Marzolino and Vice President Dave Stiles. Other Kriger-linked firms propose the nearly 620,000-square-foot Project Boson data center across the street from Essential Energy, as well as four data centers and three power plants across Bell Mountain in Dickson City.
Essential Energy’s plans have been contentious at hearings due to the power plant’s proximity to homes, schools, businesses and a popular borough park. The proposed power plant would nearly border Archbald’s Staback Park; it is opposite the Highlands Archbald residential community on Eynon Jermyn Road; and the Valley View School District’s campuses begin about half a mile away on Columbus Drive. There is also a preschool in the plaza in front of the Highlands, and a developer plans to build assisted living and skilled nursing facilities in the area.
The debate over Essential Energy has largely revolved around the conceptual nature of its plans, with opponents pressing for more specific information and invoking Archbald’s zoning criteria for credible evidence, while power plant representatives counter that specifics will come later as the development evolves and navigates the regulatory processes.
Markle, who cited his experience overseeing a fleet of 180 natural gas power plants in the United States representing about 5% of the grid, compared Essential Energy to a smaller version of the nearly 1,500-megawatt Lackawanna Energy Center in Jessup, characterizing natural gas power plants as “cookie-cutter” designs with specific protections and design elements tailored to the location and community.
Andrew Markle, left, technical lead of power generation for KCI Technologies of Mechanicsburg, and Essential Energy attorney Frank Hoegen listen to a question at an Essential Energy hearing at Valley View High School on Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2026. (CHAD SEBRING/STAFF PHOTO)
‘Credible evidence’
Richards, of Elliott Greenleaf PC in Wilkes-Barre, opened his cross-examination by asking Markle to provide his Pennsylvania engineering license number; Markle authored the two-part report that was the subject of Tuesday’s hearing and the previous Aug. 18 hearing.
“I do not have one,” Markle said, explaining he is a registered professional engineer in the province of Ontario, Canada.
W. Casey Deller, a vice president at KCI Technologies in Mechanicsburg, reviewed and sealed the report as a professional engineer in Pennsylvania, Markle said. He later defended it as a standard practice in engineering due to the difficulty of maintaining licensing across individual states and provinces, each of which has its own licensure board.
Richards also reiterated his contention that the hearing itself is a legally null because Essential Energy LLC did not exist March 12 when it submitted a zoning permit application in Archbald. The limited liability company organized with the state March 13.
Markle said he had no idea about it.
The attorney representing Stop Archbald Data Centers members referenced changing site plans and different testimony and reports from various engineers, changing the number of turbines and equipment multiple times.
“If multiple different assumptions have been provided to the borough council based on wildly varying equipment, which one is the most accurate?” Richards said, listing multiple engineers who previously testified.
It’s the normal progression of a conceptual design, where people examine different ways of approaching the same problem, Markle said.
“We’re refining the design as we’re going,” Markle said.
Citing Archbald’s zoning ordinance, Richards pointed to requirements for credible evidence, sufficient detail to indicate potential public health and safety hazards, and that the burden is on the applicant to demonstrate to the borough that the proposed use will not create a significant hazard to the public health and safety, such as fire, toxic or explosive hazards.
“Merriam-Webster defines credible as, ‘Offering reasonable grounds for being believed or trusted,’ where you are the most recent in a line of witnesses that cannot state or affirm what the site layout will be, what the required equipment will be for this project … how can your testimony offer reasonable grounds for being considered trustworthy or believable?” Richards said.
“Because this is the way things are normally done,” Markle said, drawing murmurs from the crowd. “We go from conceptual to preliminary to detailed to as-constructed to operational, and this is just the way that these these projects are produced.”
Stop Archbald Data Centers co-founder Tamara Misewicz-Healey continued a similar line of questioning, in addition to cross-examining Markle on the yet-to-be-determined routing of a natural gas pipeline to fuel the power plant.
Tamara Misewicz-Healey askes questions of Andrew Markle, left, technical lead of power generation for KCI Technologies of Mechanicsburg, and Essential Energy attorney Frank Hoegen at an Essential Energy hearing at Valley View High School on Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2026. (CHAD SEBRING/STAFF PHOTO)
“There’s natural gas on the site, and the pipelines are a part of this application, and you’re testifying that it’s safe — and pipeline safety for fire and explosion hazard is a risk factor of that safety to the community, but you cannot show us compliance today, correct?” she asked.
“If it doesn’t comply, it will not get built,” Markle said.
“Your application can’t get approved unless you show compliance,” Misewicz-Healey said.
She stressed Archbald’s 500-foot setbacks for pipelines from residential zoning districts and 750-foot setbacks from existing dwellings for natural gas pipeline compressor stations. She cited the project’s close proximity to uses like homes, schools and a playground.
“If you want to say it’s credible evidence that it’s safe, how can we ensure … setbacks from pipelines when you don’t even have the design of where they go?” she said.
If they don’t comply, it won’t be built, Markle reiterated.
“We’re not responsible for the design and the building of the pipeline,” he said. “That is the pipeline gas supplier.”
“So you’re just not going to take responsibility for that?” Misewicz-Healey said.
“No,” Markle said.
‘Fair burden’
After additional cross-examination from Valley View School District Solicitor Kyle Callejas of Joyce, Carmody & Moran PC and Highlands Archbald residents Meg Nudelman and Jim Timmons, Markle testified about the layers of protections Essential Energy would rely on to reduce risks, as well as how the power plant would work with local first responders.
Representing Essential Energy, attorney Frank Hoegen of Hoegen & Associates in Wilkes-Barre guided Markle’s testimony through questions.
Markle described two meetings with local first responders and county emergency management officials in August and September to discuss the power plant and how they would respond, explaining Archbald’s volunteer firefighters are already familiar with power plants because of the Lackawanna Energy Center in Jessup. He discussed the “defense in layers” approach Essential Energy would use to respond to emergencies, including an on-site response with their own 24/7 workers and equipment until firefighters arrive, coordinating with first responders, various fire suppression methods, sensors, emergency shutoffs, relief valves, and other measures to reduce the power plant’s risks.
“They expressed a degree of confidence that they were knowledgeable of the types of chemicals that were going to be used at the site and the type of fire response that will be required,” Markle said. “I’d say the only hesitation they had was to do with being a volunteer organization, being, you know, stretched thin. They’re hardworking guys.”
To address the potential for delayed response times, Essential Energy would “need robust engineering safeguards and procedures and codes to make sure that the emergency is mostly taken care of before the first responders arrive,” he said.
If there were an emergency, Lackawanna County’s 911 system would be able to notify residents within a certain vicinity to shelter-in-place or evacuate, though the need to evacuate would be “extremely, extremely rare, or maybe not even possible,” Markle said.
Nudelman, who lives on Foxtail Circle in the closest residential development to the proposed power plant, asked, “How can you say this is safe to be so close to a vulnerable population? Children, Valley View School, a park right next door, and it’s not just that — it’s combined.”
She described other nearby data center proposals, asking, “If you were council, would you look at the cumulative effect of all these?”
Markle said in his time overseeing 180 power plants, there were usually one or two major events a year at one of the different units, all of which were resolved without loss of life, though there was damage to property at times. The safety systems responded as they should, he said.
Councilwoman Lisa Osborne told Markle she does not feel like there’s enough for council to really understand how its firefighters would respond.
“It’s a normal tension at this part of the process because the design is conceptual at this point, and all these details get worked out,” Markle said. “We haven’t gone to a large degree of design certainty, and what we can tell you is that there is not a huge chasm between what we’re proposing at this point and the design maturity and what you see over at (Lackawanna Energy Center). It’s the same kind of systems, just scaled down.”
Power plants have been built all over the country, he said.
Council Vice President Joseph Altier III referenced Markle’s reports and its description of limited staffing faced by local first responders.
“Do you think that’s a fair burden to put on our volunteer firefighters or our neighboring towns?” Altier asked.
“I don’t know if that’s the judgment that I’m to make, but I can just tell them what our needs are, and the burden that’s required is what it is,” Markle said. “I think it’s a decision of the community to decide if it’s a fair burden.”
Archbald will hold its seventh hearing on Essential Energy on Oct. 27 at 5 p.m. at the Valley View High School auditorium, 1 Columbus Drive, Archbald, borough Solicitor Jay O’Connor announced at the conclusion of Tuesday’s hearing.