BERWYN, Pa. — If you want to see the best of high school soccer in Pennsylvania this season, wait until the district playoffs.
That’s not only when the best teams in this region of the state are in prime form and compete against each other in elimination rounds, but also when the best facet of the game itself can re-emerge.
After several years of administrative barter, the PIAA deemed 2026 the start of the no-overtime era for high school girls’ and boys’ soccer. The reasons were many; the consequences seemed like an afterthought.
But then again, there was that 1-1 tie between the current top two boys’ teams in District One’s highest classification on Tuesday.
The dissolution of OT sessions (and thus, penalty kicks) to decide outcomes in regular season soccer matches in the state should indeed have the desired positive effect: Less chance of fatigue injuries for players, earlier hours of after-school activities on school nights, less motivation for officials to bypass assignments on days that they could double up on games, etc.
All valid and well-considered points. But the overarching downer? Letting matches end in a tie saps a lot of the thrill out of the game itself.
That was never more evident than in the sudden stalemate between Lower Merion and Conestoga, two (still) undefeated Central League teams.
The Aces scored early, held the momentum until almost halftime, then spent most of the second half trying not to bend under the Pioneers’ ever-frantic pressure.
The intensity was pitch-perfect until Conestoga sophomore speedster Dylan Grilley cashed in late for a tying goal. The Pioneers almost won it before the final bell of regulation, but those last several minutes felt like a prelude to what everyone surely wanted…
An overtime answer.
Conestoga coach Angelo Capetola congratulates senior Ben Frischmann (right) during a game against Lower Merion Tuesday. (Credit: Rob Parent for OnPattison)
“We would have loved to have an opportunity for overtime,” Conestoga head coach Angelo Capetola said. “But it was a good test for both teams, both playoff-caliber teams expected to go far not only in the district tournament but hopefully make some waves in the state tournament.”
If these two elite, neighboring squads meet in either of those Class 4A playoff outings, they could answer what separates them. So far, through 10 Conestoga games and nine Lower Merion matches, neither team has suffered a loss … nor does either have a perfect record.
“Two very, very good teams going at it,” LM coach Nico Severini said. “Sometimes the game can go either way. We wanted to walk out of there with the win but I’m sure they wanted to win, too.”
Yet there seemed something a bit off with Conestoga at the start of the game, something diagnosed by first-year head coach and 23rd-season coaching staff member Angelo Capetola as, “we came out a little flat.
It was during that slow start that Lower Merion got a jump on the scoreboard.
First, Conestoga goalkeeper Ryan McLean made a nice stop on the Aces’ Ben Bradway from 25 yards out. But two minutes later, a Pioneers defender completely whiffed on a clearing kick, and LM’s Daniel Orova slashed in and chipped a shot past McLean at 32:59 for a 1-0 Aces lead.
For too long, Conestoga’s collective nerves made it look like that early edge could hold, the one-goal difference seemingly staggering. But slowly the Pioneers started to even the pitch and control the tempo. Lower Merion’s defense was up for the challenge, but when it got caught, sophomore goalie Watson Roberts stood strong.
His best moment came nine minutes into the second half: he made a superb stop, then quickly followed up on a rebound with a crowd in front of the Lower Merion net. Two minutes later, Grilley came back, speeding through the attack zone but putting a shot right into Roberts’ midsection, which he gratefully cradled.
“Last year we lost to this team 1-nothing. We came back here trying to beat them this time,” Grilley said. “We knew they were a good opponent, and it was going to be a hard battle.”
“It’s one of the best leagues in the state, so each game is difficult,” Severini added. “You just never know on a given day how the game can go.”
Despite Lower Merion’s best efforts, this one would only go to the tie column.
Conestoga (9-0-1) really ramped up its efforts as the second-half clock ticked toward the late stages. Another Grilley probe into the attack zone was stymied by Roberts, and he was somewhat fortunate when a bullet of a shot by ‘Stoga senior midfielder Luke Stienes just cleared the crossbar.
“He had a phenomenal game,” Severini said of his goalie. “One or two goal line saves, and their striker was very fast to the ball. I think our goalkeeper had a tremendous game, and sometimes the ball goes in, sometimes it doesn’t. He made some clutch saves to keep that clean sheet toward the last minutes.”
But as the clock ticked down to seven, Watson’s luck ran out. He came out to field a loose ball, and because Grilley knows how to turn on an afterburner, it was the wrong decision. The Conestoga sophomore beat the Lower Merion sophomore to the ball and deposited a 1-1 tie with 6:57 left to play.
“I expected him to come out and jump on it,” Grilley said of Watson. “I interpreted it as a ball for me. People know I’m quick. In my mind, it’s one of the strengths I have.
“It felt great. I wish we could have gone on to the win there. But it just felt good to get the goal, and get the tie.”
Roberts managed to shake off the disappointment to make a one-handed save with 3:30 left, which was either team’s best chance the rest of the way. In another year, it would have only been a prelude to an intriguing and exciting overtime session.
“It’s not how we wanted it, obviously,” Lower Merion senior midfielder Ayden Foote said. “But a game like that, with two very good teams, we’ll take it. The way it went down, it sucks; only six minutes left. But I’m proud of everyone. The way everybody stepped up.
“The only thing we can do now is keep our heads up. But yeah, I’m excited. I’d love to see them again.”