ALLENTOWN, Pa. — Three years after the October 7 attacks in Israel, members of the Lehigh Valley Jewish community say the anniversary remains a day of grief, remembrance and reflection.

For Aaron Gorodzinsky, director of development for the Jewish Federation of the Lehigh Valley, the attack created a dividing line that remains evident three years later.

“There is a Jewish community before October seven, and there is a Jewish community after October seven,” Gorodzinsky said.

Jeri Zimmerman, executive director of the Jewish Federation of the Lehigh Valley, said members of the community are still processing what happened.

“I think everyone is grappling with, you know, trying to make sense of any of it,” Zimmerman said.

About 1,200 people were killed when Hamas-led militants attacked southern Israel on Oct. 7, 2023. Another 251 people were taken hostage. More than 350 people were killed at the Nova music festival.

This year’s anniversary is different in one significant way: It is the first October 7 commemoration since all of the hostages, both living and deceased, were returned from Gaza.

For Gorodzinsky, that changes the way the community can approach the anniversary.

“For the last two years, we were still holding our breath, hoping that the hostages were going to come back, and we couldn’t really start even mourning those who we lost on October seven in a real way, knowing that there were still people under the tunnels, under the guns of Hamas,” he said.

That leaves the community considering how to commemorate the attack now that waiting for the return of hostages is no longer part of the anniversary.

“What do we do as a community to commemorate the day in a way that is able to present the pain and the suffering and the ideas of what happened during the day, where we’re not concentrating half of it on bringing the hostages home?” Gorodzinsky said.

Lehigh Valley commemoration focuses on remembrance

The Jewish Federation of the Lehigh Valley is holding a commemoration Wednesday evening at the Jewish Community Center of the Lehigh Valley in Allentown.

Students from the Muhlenberg College and Lehigh University Hillels are participating in the program, which begins with readings and prayers. The Federation says the event is open to the public with registration required.

The program also includes a screening of The Road Between Us: The Ultimate Rescue, a documentary about retired Israeli general Noam Tibon’s effort to reach his son and his son’s family during the October 7 attack.

The Federation’s own October publication describes the commemoration as an opportunity to remember those killed and reflect on the continuing impact of the attack, while noting the participation of local Jewish college students.

For Zimmerman, remembrance also means considering how October 7 changed the community itself.

“I think it’s a reminder of, you know, our own humanity, moral clarity, decency,” she said.

Three years later, she said members of the community are still trying to maintain their sense of openness while living with what happened.

“We want to be a warm, welcoming and open community,” Zimmerman said. “And I think this new sense of loss of innocence post October 7 is a new reality that we’re managing.”