Pocono Mountain West coach Jim McCarroll is the only coach the program has ever had.
He has had a lot of quality kids in his 25 seasons in charge of the Panthers, but he may have never had a pair of brothers as talented as Christian and Teddy Stiehler.
The two are driving forces for McCarroll’s team, which is in action on Thursday night as Week 7 of the Eastern Pennsylvania Conference football schedule kicks off with a pair of games in Monroe County.
Pocono Mountain West is at Stroudsburg, while Pocono Mountain East is at East Stroudsburg South.
While both East and South knew they would be going to the District 11 5A playoffs before the season began, the Panthers and Mounties are trying to secure one of the spots in the D11 6A field and this game could go a long way in determining who gets in and who doesn’t. If the season ended Thursday morning, West would be in as the No. 8 seed.
If the Panthers are going to snap a four-game losing streak to Stroudsburg and avenge last year’s 30-15 loss, they are going to need big efforts from the Stiehler brothers, who represent the twin towers of the program as juniors.
“Both Christian and Teddy are playing lights out,” McCarroll said. “Christian has really grown up on the defensive side of the ball this year. Last year, he put up 1,000 yards rushing and this year he’s almost at 900 yards going into this week. He has been running hard and at times he’s doing it on his own because we’ve been struggling with our line a little bit.
“He’s a beast. He’s 6-foot-3 and now 245 pounds and as a running back, he’s hard to bring down when he’s going north and south. And he has speed. He can break away and at his size, you see some defensive kids not wanting to tackle him. He has been a tremendous asset for us and we’ve been leaning on him a lot. He’s our workhorse.”
At his linebacker position he has 100 tackles the last two years and McCarroll said he’s even better with his technique.
“He used to play defensive end before we moved up as a freshman and he started playing linebacker,” McCarroll said. “He was still learning as a freshman and sophomore, but you could really see it click in for him now at linebacker as a junior.”
As for his younger brother by a few minutes, Teddy Stiehler, who is listed at 6-foot-7, and weighs about 210, has come into his own on both sides of the ball.
“He has a motor that doesn’t quit on defense,” McCarroll said. “And, he has definitely turned up his game offensively. We play him at tight end and wide receiver and he has done a much better job of going up and catching the ball.”
McCarroll said the Stiehler boys are not only great athletes, but also strong leaders.
“They really work hard and their teammates rally around them because they are great leaders,” McCarroll said. “… We’re looking for them to continue to get better and hopefully help us make the district playoffs. Teddy is now much more confident. Starting the last two years on both the football and basketball teams has made him more confident and he’s going to get in the backfield and create havoc in football and he’s also going to be a force in basketball.”
As for the game against Stroudsburg, McCarroll said it is arguably the biggest game of the season to this point.
“Our goal is to get into districts and we know we have to take care of Stroudsburg to get there,” he said. “This is the game that could put us over the top. It’s a huge one for us. They have a good quarterback in Jack Mitchell and then have Keegan Munch, who is a good slotback/linebacker and their running back Keyen Johnson is legit. They have athletes all over the field. We just have to care of business and not hurt ourselves by putting the ball on the ground.”
As for the EPC’s Monroe County Division, McCarroll said, “Everybody’s kind of similar. North is struggling, but you’ve got East Stroudsburg South, PV, East, Stroudsburg and us and we’ve all got pretty good teams. So I expect all of these games to be close the rest of the way. Our issue is depth. We only have six or seven linemen to begin with and then you lose three to injuries and you’re playing JVs. But our kids aren’t quitting. We’re in these games and our defense has played well. We’ve just got to put points on the board.”
Pocono Mountain East (4-2, 1-2) at East Stroudsburg South (2-4, 1-2)
The storylines: This could be a District 11 5A playoff preview. Both teams are coming off losses — the Cardinals lost to Easton 39-0 and the Cavaliers fell to Bethlehem Catholic 49-14. East had trouble getting its ground game going against Easton, managing just 61 yards on 25 carries. South only had 63 yards on 24 carries against Becahi. East won last year’s game 30-7 behind 247 yards rushing. Ceejay Serfass had a 16-yard TD run as part of a dominant second half when East outscored South 23-0.
Players to watch: East’s Prince David Albino is fourth in the league in catches with 27 for 371 yards and three TDs. Serfass has thrown for 809 yards and six scores and Evan Garrett is averaging 7.4 yards per carry and has scored nine times. South’s Alex Perez and Michael Udeh have combined for 94 tackles.
Keith Groller’s pick: Pocono Mountain East 26-21
Pocono Mountain West (4-2, 2-1) at Stroudsburg (2-4, 0-3)
The storylines: This is a game with large ramifications for District 11 6A’s playoff chase. At the moment, West is clinging to the eighth and last spot while Stroudsburg is on the outside. The Panthers are coming off their second shutout loss of the season, this time to Liberty. The Mounties have lost four in a row after a 2-0 start and have scored just 32 points in the losing streak.
Players to watch: West’s Christian Stiehler leads the EPC in rushing with 892 yards. He is averaging 8.3 yards and per carry and also leads the league in rushing TDs with 12. Teddy Stiehler is among the league leaders with six sacks. Panthers sophomore quarterback Dominic DiCicco has thrown for 543 yards and two touchdowns. Stroudsburg’s Jack Mitchell has thrown for 1,078 yards and eight TDs and Keyen Johnson has 702 yards rushing. Stroudsburg’s Kevin Owusu-Ansah has six sacks.
Keith Groller’s pick: Pocono Mountain West 21-14