Tensions between the Millcreek Fire and EMS Commission and the Belle Valley Fire Department escalated Thursday night following a pair of closely divided votes that could have significant financial consequences for the department.
During its meeting, the Millcreek Fire and EMS Commission voted 6-3 to recommend that Millcreek Township terminate its current contract with the Belle Valley Fire Department. In a separate 6-3 vote, the commission also recommended that township relief funding be distributed only to Millcreek’s partnered fire departments.
If ultimately approved, the move could leave Belle Valley without access to more than $90,000 in funding.
Belle Valley Fire Chief John Rainey strongly disagreed with the recommendations, which come amid a months-long disagreement between Belle Valley and the Millcreek Fire Department over a proposed cooperation agreement.
On September 1, Millcreek officials gave Belle Valley 30 days to sign a new cooperation agreement designed to outline how the departments work together. However, Belle Valley has not signed the document, arguing that the proposed agreement would diminish the department’s independence and authority as a volunteer fire company.
Millcreek Fire Chief Mike Cliff said the township is not attempting to force Belle Valley into signing the agreement but maintains that the partnership framework is necessary moving forward.
Belle Valley’s board is scheduled to vote on the proposed agreement on November 4. The decision could have major implications for the department’s future relationship with the township. If the agreement is not approved, Belle Valley would no longer qualify for relief funding distributed by Millcreek Township, which is scheduled to be allocated on November 15.
The dispute highlights ongoing questions about funding, governance, and cooperation among emergency service providers in Millcreek, with both sides standing firm as a key deadline approaches.