Lackawanna County’s attempt to push back its long-anticipated property reassessment fell short Friday when President Judge James Gibbons swiftly denied a request for an emergency one-year extension.

The county filed its petition late Friday morning, asking to move the implementation date from 2026 to 2027. Less than two hours later, Gibbons issued a brief, one-sentence order turning down the request without explanation.

The decision puts the county back on track to certify new property values by Saturday. Certification is required so the county, school districts, and municipalities can calculate updated tax rates for 2026.

The $5.1 million reassessment, conducted by Tyler Technologies of Plano, Texas, has been the subject of months of political debate. Tobin has repeatedly defended the accuracy of the new values and had planned to meet the original Nov. 15 certification deadline.

Tobin met with FOX56 reporter Elizabeth Haikes on Thursday and explained the process and the problems with delaying the reassessment.

But the county’s political landscape shifted in recent weeks. Newly appointed Commissioner Brenda Sacco, a Democrat sworn in Oct. 22, joined Republican Commissioner Chris Chermak to form a bipartisan board majority. Chermak has long pushed for a delay, and Sacco signaled early on that she wanted more time to evaluate the reassessment. On Friday, the county solicitor asked the court to halt implementation.

Commissioner Bill Gaughan opposed any postponement, pointing to Tyler Technologies’ internal review that deemed the reassessment highly accurate. Gaughan also warned that delaying the process could cost taxpayers an additional $2.5 million, citing an estimate from a Tyler manager.

Gaughan did not hold back in his criticism of Chermak and Sacco.

“Chris Chermak spent months lying to the public about reassessment — lying about the law, lying about the court order, lying about the consequences of ignoring it, and now lying about me. His latest claim, accusing me of “getting to” the plaintiffs’ attorney, is so absurd it would be funny if it weren’t so embarrassing. I’ve never met her, never spoken to her, and — despite Chermak’s fever dream — I don’t have a “legal team.”

Gaughan also took the opportunity to remind taxpayers that Chermak was part of the administration that he blames for the county’s fiscal problems:

“Chris Chermak was the minority commissioner during the last administration — the supposed “watchdog,” the check on power.

Yet while the county’s finances deteriorated, he sat silently, tail wagging, rubber-stamping bad decisions and pretending everything was fine. The watchdog wasn’t watching anything. He wasn’t even barking. He was asleep on the porch while the house caught fire.”

“This entire crisis was created because Commissioner Chermak chose politics over the public. He pandered, he stalled, and when reality caught up to him, he blamed everyone in sight — me, the attorneys, the plaintiffs, the process, the calendar, the mail, and now, apparently, the shadows on the wall.

Chris Chermak tried to MAGA his way through a court-ordered reassessment. And just like all MAGA fantasies, it collapsed the second it encountered facts, law, and basic common sense.”

Commissioner Chermak pushed back on Gaughan’s comments and stuck by his desire to delay the reassessment, going back as far as early discussions when the county was just coming out of COVID-19 restrictions.

“Going back a few years, we were just really getting towards the end of the shutdown, when the previous commissioner majority passed the reassessment. I was a no vote. I thought this is poor timing, we’re just coming out of a pandemic. People aren’t working. Businesses are closed, people are still home-like it’s been 50 plus years. I think we could wait another year. This wasn’t an emergency.”

Chermak also expressed concerns about the legality of notifications that went out and the ability of local businesses to get their properties appraised. “I’m looking at the notifications that went out, but they don’t follow the statute, so they’re not really legal. People weren’t afforded the correct amount of time to file their further appeals. Then you look at commercial properties. I’ve been saying the commercial properties have to have professional appraisals done. There aren’t enough appraisers in the Northeast to handle all of them, so there wasn’t enough time for them to get their ducks in a row. This afternoon, the assessment numbers will be certified. “

“I think it makes total sense and to give people just a little more time that have to have an appeal, and then these companies that would need to get appraisals would have ample time to get appraisals, and then we’ll initiate it January of 2027, you know, this is revenue neutral, so it won’t affect anything.”

Then, Chermak addressed Gaughan’s statements: “Right now, most counties, the commissioners work together; it doesn’t happen here. Bill Gaughan is the most hated person in Lackawanna County. He treats people disrespectfully; I don’t care how he treats me, but he treats the public disrespectfully, and he wants to be the king in charge. It doesn’t work that way. I don’t understand his motives, I don’t understand his agenda, and I certainly don’t understand why he is such a nasty individual. In most counties, the commissioners work together; it doesn’t happen here.”

“I took an oath to protect the people of Lackawanna County and to do what is right, even when it is difficult, and even when decisions don’t go our way. Although our motion was denied, I will continue to do everything in my power to make sure every property owner gets a fair chance, accurate information, and the opportunity they deserve.”

Commissioner Sacco also disagreed with the decision to move forward with the reassessment certification:

“As a County Commissioner, I believe that a reassessment in Lackawanna County was imperative, but my foremost responsibility was to ensure that any property reassessment conducted in Lackawanna County was accurate, fair, and equitable for every taxpayer. This could have been fixed months ago, and the reassessment could have moved forward properly and responsibly. Instead, Commissioner Gaughan chose to file a frivolous lawsuit which kept me out of the seat for 8 months, despite the Supreme Court ruling that I should have been seated. In my humble personal opinion, his personal motives and refusal to act when it mattered stalled our ability to correct this process and placed an unnecessary burden on the taxpayers. The decision to request an extension and file an Emergency Motion for the modification of the order related to the Lackawanna County Reassessment was not about politics; it was about principle and fairness.”

With Gibbons’ ruling, the county’s reassessment appears poised to move ahead on schedule.