Trick-or-treating commonly involves artificial ingredients and food additives. But kids at a Fayette County elementary school got more than they bargained for at Wednesday’s “Trunk or Treat” event – where, according to Albert Gallatin Area School District Superintendent Christopher Pegg, the shaved ice on offer may have been laced with broken glass and insulin. Mark Howard, the owner of Have an Ice Day Shaved Ice, which provided the tricky treats, attributed the unintentional contamination to a mixup involving his dog’s insulin. While frightful, the incident fortunately didn’t result in any injuries.

Keep reading for more winners and losers!