If your Zillow scrolling has gotten a little too predictable, here’s something that definitely breaks the algorithm: a private island in Ohio is officially for sale.
Mouse Island — a roughly seven-acre slice of land floating just off the coast of Catawba Island in Lake Erie — has hit the market with a $5 million price tag. And yes, it comes with a pretty impressive résumé: the island was once owned by President Rutherford B. Hayes.
Located near Port Clinton (about an hour east of Toledo), Mouse Island offers the kind of privacy most Ohioans only experience while camping in the middle of nowhere — except this time, you’re surrounded by water instead of cornfields. The wooded island features mature trees, rocky shorelines, and sweeping 360-degree views of Lake Erie, with access only by private boat.
According to the listing, the property is zoned for private use and is ideal for a custom-built retreat, an off-grid getaway, or a long-term investment for someone with big lakefront dreams. Despite its secluded feel, Mouse Island is just minutes from the mainland and close to vacationland staples like Cedar Point, marinas, restaurants, and the Lake Erie Islands.
History buffs might be especially intrigued.
Hayes once had a cottage on the island (it no longer exists), adding a presidential footnote to what’s already a rare real estate opportunity. These days, the listing emphasizes tranquility and exclusivity — so much so that potential visitors are warned not to approach the island without approval.
For those curious about the logistics: a 30-year fixed mortgage at current average rates would land at roughly $25,000 per month. Casual browsing encouraged, actual island ownership optional.
Mouse Island has been listed on Realtor.com since July 2025, and while there are no open houses planned (understandably), interested buyers can request a private showing. Because when it comes to owning your own Ohio island, apparently you have to ask first.
You can view the full listing here.