ESPN personality Stephen A. Smith sharply criticized the Pittsburgh Steelers on Monday, arguing the organization should have interviewed former player and current ESPN analyst Ryan Clark for its vacant head coaching position before finalizing its decision to hire Mike McCarthy.
Speaking on First Take, Smith says he was “very upset” with how the Steelers handled the search. He stressed his comments were sincere and rooted in respect for Clark’s background and franchise ties. Smith said he was not exaggerating or speaking hypothetically. He added that Clark deserved serious consideration rather than being overlooked entirely.
“I’m not joking about this and I’m dead serious. I believe that Ryan Clark should have been interviewed for the job,” Smith said during the segment, underscoring his frustration with the lack of outreach from Pittsburgh despite Clark’s extensive history with the organization.
Clark spent eight of his 13 NFL seasons with the Steelers and played a key role on the Super Bowl XLIII championship team. Since retiring, he has built a prominent media career. He is now one of ESPN’s most recognizable NFL analysts. Clark regularly offers insight on leadership, locker room dynamics, and organizational culture.
Smith reinforced his argument by pointing to recent league precedent, noting that former quarterback Philip Rivers received a head coaching interview with the Buffalo Bills despite having no formal coaching experience.
“Philip Rivers got interviewed by the Buffalo Bills,” Smith says. “I’m just saying, you Pittsburgh Steelers, what’s up?”
Smith said the relationship between Clark and the Steelers remains active. He alleged the organization regularly seeks Clark’s advice on football matters. According to Smith, that ongoing dialogue made the lack of an interview more puzzling. He added the decision felt unusual for a franchise that values loyalty and continuity.
“”I know they love RC, and they know he’s a Steeler for life. I know they pick up the phone and call him. Deferring to him and ask his advice and stuff like that,” Smith said, adding that team officials regularly consult Clark for guidance and perspective. “How come you can’t interview the brother?”
The Steelers ultimately chose McCarthy, a Super Bowl-winning coach with extensive head coaching experience, most recently leading the Dallas Cowboys. The hire signals a desire for immediate structure and stability as Pittsburgh looks to reassert itself as a consistent contender in the AFC.
Barrett Media produces daily content on the music, news, and sports media industries. Sign up for our newsletters to stay updated and get the latest informed right in your inbox.

