OLD FORGE, LACKAWANNA CO. (WOLF) — A well-known Old Forge restaurant tied to a years-long homicide case is preparing to reopen, marking a significant moment for the community.
Ghigiarelli’s Restaurant announced it will resume operations this weekend with limited takeout hours on Friday and Saturday from 4:30 p.m. to 7 p.m. Orders can be placed by phone between 11 a.m. and 1 p.m., and the business says it will accept credit and debit cards only for now. The restaurant will offer its signature red and white pizza, priced at $14.90.
Owners say they plan to expand service in the coming weeks, with hours expected Wednesday through Sunday.
The reopening comes after nearly a decade of closure following the disappearance of owner Robert Baron in 2017. Baron, 58, was reported missing after leaving the restaurant and never returning home. Investigators later determined he was killed during a robbery at the business.
In 2023, skeletal remains found near Pagnotti Park were identified as Baron through DNA testing. The following year, a jury convicted Justin Schuback of first-degree murder, burglary, and robbery in connection with the case.
For years, the restaurant on South Main Street remained closed, serving as a reminder of the tragedy that deeply impacted the Old Forge community.
Now, with the business reopening its doors—albeit in a limited capacity—owners say they are grateful for the support and hope to welcome customers back once again.
Social media users were ecstatic. Here’s a sample of comments:
Comment with Bubbles
BE THE FIRST TO COMMENT
Is this a dream??? Pinch me please!! -LindaThat’s the Best news I’ve heard from NEPA, in a long time! – ToddI’m so happy and excited Old Forge Native and the memories and good times my whole childhood. – KevinThis is absolutely fantastic news. I will be calling tomorrow at 11 AM for two trays of red and two trays of white. – JasonWelcome back, you were REALLY missed! – Linda