The candidates
Brooks has built his campaign around organized labor and working-class appeal and has gained backing from prominent Democrats and labor groups, including support connected to both progressive and establishment wings of the party. His message focuses heavily on wages, public safety and union rights.
“This election is about working-class people,” he told WHYY News. “It’s that simple, and right now, there’s nobody representing us.”
Brooks received endorsements from Gov. Josh Shapiro, state Reps. Peter Schweyer and Mike Schlossberg, the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee and the Working Families Party.
Political observers have noted that his endorsements and fundraising may have helped move him toward the front of the field, but some were surprised that the party engaged so heavily before voters choose their nominee.
Borick said it’s traditionally uncommon for a party apparatus to “put their thumbs on the scale” in a party primary, but that it’s likely a long-term strategy.
“This seems to be part of the effort of those in party leadership and elected officials to look for a path that they think might be best for them moving forward in the general election,” he said.
Schweyer said that “ultimately, voters will make the final decision” who their nominee is and that many people “overvalue” endorsements.
“As somebody who has endorsed Bob, I just want to make sure that doors are open to him, that people are giving him a look,” he said.
Crosswell said he was “disappointed” that the party intervened on Brooks’ behalf, but that he’s still confident about his campaign.
“I think you’re seeing the outrage here in Lehigh Valley,” he told WHYY News. “People are really mad, and I think it’s actually backfired. There are four credible candidates in this race — not just one of us. And the people of Lehigh Valley don’t think they want a thumb on this scale.”
Ryan Crosswell, a Democratic candidate for U.S. Congress in the Lehigh Valley, speaks to voters in Allentown. (Carmen Russell-Sluchansky)
Crosswell, a former federal prosecutor with the Department of Justice’s Public Integrity Section, resigned after the Trump administration demanded the department drop corruption charges against New York City Mayor Eric Adams in an alleged quid pro quo arrangement.
He said that his role at the DOJ makes him the best candidate to take on Mackenzie and Republicans in Congress.
“I think the reason our campaign has gotten so much grassroots support is people are concerned about the affordability of gas, of groceries, of health insurance, but also, they see the most corrupt administration in U.S. history,” Crosswell said. “Administration abuse of power is a kitchen-table issue.”
However, he added that his prior work may also be why he didn’t get early party backing.
“I never expected to be the endorsement candidate,” he said. “When you’re a corruption prosecutor, you don’t get invited to a lot of cocktail parties in Washington and Harrisburg.”
Both Crosswell and Brooks were the targets of negative ads, which appeared to support the candidate McClure. An ad paid for by a newly formed political action committee, Lead Left, accused Brooks of being associated with election deniers and Crosswell of working for “Trump’s Justice Department.”
The same group also ran ads in a Nebraska Democratic primary, attacking one candidate as “MAGA” and accusing him of “betraying Nebraska Democrats” in support of another Democrat. Lead Left’s website says it “stands against MAGA extremists who will infect our country with Donald Trump’s agenda.”
However, Punchbowl News reported that metadata tied to the PAC’s website included links to WinRed, the leading Republican fundraising platform. Little information about Lead Left is publicly available.
Borick said such tactics are becoming common.
“We’ve seen this emerging trend in American politics where opposition parties like to engage more so than ever in their opponent’s primaries and try to leverage outcomes that might benefit them in the general election,” he said.
Both Brooks and Crosswell said that the revelation shows Republicans would prefer a challenge by McClure in November, rather than either of them.
“They’re petrified,” Brooks said. “If they’re going to spend $1.2 million against us, they obviously don’t want to face us.”
McClure did not respond to multiple requests for comment through his campaign. However, an analysis of his fundraising shows he may be a weaker candidate going into the general election. As of the end of April, McClure had raised just over $300,000, which he supplemented with another $200,000 of his own cash. Obando-Derstine, who was handpicked by Wild to run, raised a little short of $600,000.
By contrast, Brooks raised nearly $1.2 million, but Crosswell has shown the most prowess in fundraising, bringing in more than $1.75 million.
That may factor into Crosswell’s confidence.
“We’re going to win,” he said, adding that, if he doesn’t, he would support the nominee “from day one.”
Whether national Democrats’ or Republicans’ attempts to put a thumb on the scale in the primary works, Borick said that given how much the cycle favors Democrats this year, any of the candidates would have a “path to victory.”
“They all have their own challenges as candidates, and they’ll come up against a well-funded incumbent,” he said. “But, if you look at their profiles and you look at what they might bring to the table, you could find advantages they might be able to utilize in a general election against Congressman Mackenzie.”