The Pittsburgh Public Schools board voted 6-2 with one abstention Wednesday to approve a realignment plan that calls to shutter nine public school buildings and shift many others, despite public pushback.

“It’s always been about, ‘How do we position our district to not only perform for the young people that we have today, but also be ready to perform for the young people that would be in our trust for years to come?’” board President Gene Walker said. “While these changes are difficult, for me, the decision has not been.”

In addition to Walker, board members Dwayne Barker, Yael Silk, Eva Diodati, Tracey Reed and Tawana Cook Purnell voted in favor of the plan.

Devon Taliaferro and Emma Yourd voted against.

Erikka Grayson abstained, citing her position as Senior Clubhouse Director for the Estelle S. Campbell Boys & Girls Club. The organization recieved a state grant to provide out-of-school time programming at Arsenal Middle School, a school slated for closure. That would create an appearance of a conflict of interest, Grayson said.

“I understand the difficult realities facing our district, including declining enrollment, financial challenges and aging facilities, and I recognize no one takes the decisions lightly,” Grayson said. “My continued hope is that every student, educator and family across our district has access to the resources and opportunities and support needed to strengthen outcomes for years to come.”

Proponents of the “Future-Ready Facilities Plan” say the plan will improve equity and opportunities for students districtwide, while opponents say the plan lacks clarity and transparency, and that the shifts would be disruptive to students’ educations.

Set to close at the end of next school year are the Student Achievement Center, Friendship PreK-5 (Montessori), Schiller 6-8, Manchester PreK-8, Fulton PreK-5, Miller PreK-5 and Woolslair PreK-5 school.

Spring Hill PreK-5 and Morrow would close at the end of the 2028-29 school year once renovations to Northview PreK-5 would be completed. Several schools would shift to different buildings, and nearly all elementary-level magnet programs would be phased out.

Pittsburgh Public Schools officials considered a school closure plan in November but voted it down. In January, they decided to reconsider it.

The plan has received much public pushback.

Those opposed say many questions and concerns remain unanswered. They expressed a lack of confidence in PPS’ ability to implement the plan and called for more community feedback.

Taliaferro, whose district includes five of the nine closing school buildings, took the public feedback to heart.

“They deserve somebody who is going to represent them authentically but not giving in to whoever or whatever, but to be able to make sure that we are moving in the right direction, that we are making the right decisions for children,” Taliaferro said.

Cook Purnell expressed faith in PPS administration’s ability to implement the plan.

“Any benefits far outweigh any perceived risks and my decision will be based on what is the common good,” she said.

Proponents of the plan say it addresses uneven enrollment and underutilized buildings, and provides more equitable and academic access across the district.

Diodati said the plan might lead to enrollment growth in PPS. She said there are academic, accessibility and programming gaps among students currently.

“It is selfish, I think, for us to say we are only going to save certain schools and to heck with the rest of them,” Diodati said. “We picked these schools because of their locations, because of their situations, and we would have seen similar pushback if we had picked another nine different schools. Everybody agrees that we have to close buildings, nobody wants to pick the buildings. I know, it’s hard, I don’t want to do any of this.”

Reed acknowledged closing schools is difficult. She belives PPS can look to the Baltimore City Public Schools to implement a positive school realignment plan.

Centering students with the most challenges will ultimately create a better system, she said.

“We have to get some things in order before we can start to make the kinds of changes that our kinds fundamentally deserve,” Reed said. “They should not be going to schools where they’re not getting what they need.”