The city’s Planning Commission has recommended a bill that would make inclusionary zoning — a policy requiring developers to include a certain percentage of affordable apartments in large new developments — not mandatory for developers in most Pittsburgh neighborhoods.
The Planning Commission’s nine members recommended the change Tuesday; the bill now returns to Pittsburgh City Council. This latest version of the legislation includes voluntary incentives for developers to add affordable units, such as allowing additional height or density in new buildings.
The units will only have to be affordable for 20 years, rather than the 35 years suggested by city planning staff, a point of significant discussion in the meeting.
Several speakers Tuesday afternoon said 20 years was far too short a term.
“Increasingly, the national best practice has been to try to move toward permanent affordability tenures,” said Dave Breingan, co-director of neighborhood organization Lawrenceville Together, who addressed commission members. “Thirty-five years is already watered down.”
“To reduce the term from 35 years is to erode the public benefit of the program for the residents who need it the most, and that is unacceptable… We need long-term affordability, at least 35 years, but ideally longer,” said Maddy McGrady, a co-chair of the Pittsburgh Housing Justice Table, which advocates for more affordable housing.
But Planning Commission Member David Vatz, who has been critical of inclusionary zoning mandates, said the body wanted to “make the program something that developers will actually use.”
Similarly, member Justin Hunt said he feared a 35-year affordability period would “hinder the program’s success” and cause developers to opt out.
City planning staff had proposed a 35-year period to match the existing affordability timeframe in parts of the city where inclusionary zoning is mandatory, align with other parts of the zoning code, and conform to rules in other affordable housing programs. Planners also cited research showing that longer affordability terms did not harm affordable housing production under inclusionary zoning policies elsewhere.
Mandatory inclusionary zoning is in place in four Pittsburgh neighborhoods: Lawrenceville, Oakland, Polish Hill, and Bloomfield, and would still remain mandatory in those areas under this legislation.
While there was some debate during the meeting, there were only a handful of people giving public comments. It was a marked departure from last year’s 11-hour marathon with hours of public testimony for an earlier version of the bill, which would have made inclusionary zoning mandatory citywide. The inclusionary zoning mandate was a signature policy of former Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey, who lost a primary election last year to Mayor Corey O’Connor.
Supporters of an IZ mandate argue it is a tool to create much needed affordable apartments, and that it helps keep neighborhoods more economically diverse.
Opponents of the mandatory policy argued it would have been too costly and could have, in fact, hurt overall affordability by depressing apartment construction. They also said it didn’t make sense for every part of the city. The policy has also faced legal challenges.
The legislation Planning Commission members recommended Tuesday also moved forward two much less contentious zoning changes. One would permit by-right accessory dwelling units, sometimes called “granny flats,” which are smaller apartments that aren’t the primary use of a property, such as a converted garage. The other would remove parking minimums for new developments. The bill would not prohibit new parking spaces or structures.
The bill now returns to Pittsburgh City Council — which narrowly approved an earlier version of the bill last year — for a vote.
Council must hold at least one more public hearing on the legislation, with 21 days advance notice.