PHILADELPHIA – The line of questioning has been worn almost beyond recognition, but Kyle Schwarber found a nugget of truth within it Monday night.
The Phillies slugger was endeavoring to win the Home Run Derby before home fans at Citizens Bank Park. The only decibels to rival the pops from the sellout crowd of 43,863 when Schwarber homered in the semifinals and finals were cheers when his opponents’ swings fell short of the fence. The exuberance greeting each miss by Willson Contreras and Jordan Walker – and the deflationary exhale each time one sailed into the stands – was palpable.
Schwarber felt it, even as he was focused on the competition. The six non-Phillie Derby participants did, too.
“It was funny, all the guys were walking up when they were getting introduced, and they’re like, man, the hometown cooking’s real here,” Schwarber said. “And I was like, yeah, it is. This is Philadelphia. They want their guys to go out there and do it, and they’re going to try to will the other guys not to.”
The moment was quintessentially Philadelphia, in a long weekend of festivities that showcased the city’s sporting atmosphere again. And shy of hackneyed paeans to the greatness of Phillies fans, it’s difficult on nights like Monday and Tuesday not to feel that there is something different about games in this city.
It was always comical that it had been three decades since the last All-Star Game in Philadelphia, Veterans Stadium hosting the 1996 and 1976 editions after Shibe Park did in 1952 and 1943. That was true in 2019, when the game was awarded to the city, when then 15 years into Citizens Bank Park’s existence it had not been treated to a Midsummer Classic.
Tuesday was worth the wait, but it made a mockery of how long it’s taken to return. And at the risk of knighting Philadelphia as somehow special from other towns – well, it kind of showed itself to be.
“I felt like it was a great atmosphere (Monday), and then obviously tonight, intros, the game, a lot of the in-game things that they were able to do, it was top to bottom,” Schwarber said. “I felt like it’s been an unbelievable All-Star Game, and our fans should be really proud of themselves.”
With respect to the need to rotate the summer spectacle among the league’s 27 other cities, not all baseball towns are created equal. It may be circumstance – part history, part geography – that Philadelphia is one of eight cities to host at least five All-Star Games, with old-guard or two-team towns like New York, Chicago and St. Louis. But if merit determines where future games go, consider Philadelphia for an accelerated timeline. You can plop a sparkling ballpark into a suburban expanse and call it a pro venue, but you can’t astroturf atmospheres like this, no matter how much canned music, pyrotechnics and sponsored spots you pipe in.
The fandom does occasionally descend into a caricature of itself. The cheers for Bonner grad and Aldan native Kevin McGonigle were at least as loud the boos for his inactive Detroit Tigers teammate and member of the 2022 Houston Astros Justin Verlander. The smorgasbord of boos for the non-Phillie National League starters – the Mets Juan Soto, three Dodgers who vanquished the Phillies in last year’s National League Division Series, and two Atlanta Braves – was a heckling decathlon. There were still boos for Derby champ Walker, at a delay as though Phillies fans saw him, took a moment to recall the sins he’d committed the night before and responded, eliciting a grin from Walker.
The players are in on the joke. And that elevates it all.
“I think just the number of people that were booed was probably what made it funny, in my mind, at least,” said Corbin Carroll, still the antagonist from his exploits in the 2023 NLCS.
“They were laughing. They understand it. They get it,” Bryce Harper said. “They understand the madness behind what makes this place great. Any player in baseball, they’d love to play here. I know that. You see how incredible our fanbase is, how incredible it is in October, how different it is in October.”
“You see them all smiling,” Phillies pitcher Jesus Luzardo said. “I think everyone enjoys it. I think some guys enjoy being the villain. I think they love the passion from these fans. It comes with the territory. You get booed, and it’s almost like a badge of honor.”
Much as the boos get attention, so should the moments of raucous acceptance. When the camera panned down the line of National League pitchers and reserves, you didn’t need to know when the alphabetical order hit “P.” The crowd introduced Harper with an explosion of noise that drowned out the public address.
The cheers applied just as loudly for South Jersey’s Mike Trout, surely with the fervent hope attached that he and his no-trade clause could allow this ballpark to be his home in three weeks’ time.
“Being from around this area, to be able to come back and feel that welcome, it’s huge,” Trout said. “… When I played here before, it’s a pretty good ovation. So, I think that means a lot because I know how Philly fans are when an opposing player comes in here. It’s usually pretty rough.”
The competitive value of all the noise is certainly debatable. The Phillies’ recent home playoff form weighs in on the matter. And all the fans didn’t help the National League hit the ball any better in a 4-0 loss to the American League than it did in assisting the Phillies against the Dodgers last year.
But the All-Star Game is spectacle. And Philadelphia supplied it in abundance – and in a way that is unquestionably different than many other places.
“It’s what Philly is,” Harper said. “It’s just a lot of fun to play here. I love this place. I’ve said it since Day 1. I loved coming in here as an opposing player; you kind of understand the madness as well. It’s just always fun to come into this ballpark and play.”
Contact Matthew De George at mdegeorge@delcotimes.com