Lionel Messi, Pelé, Cristiano Ronaldo and Paul O’Neill.
One of those names does not belong.
But with the FIFA World Cup Final on Sunday, there might not be a better time to revisit one of the strangest and most inexplicable plays ever made on a baseball diamond.
Thirty-seven Julys ago, on a misty night in South Philadelphia, O’Neill authored the best kick in the sport’s history.
It was July 5, 1989. The Reds were struggling. Former Phillie and baseball’s all-time hits leader Pete Rose was managing them. A month later, Rose would be famously and permanently banned from baseball.
O’Neill was 26 then, still with Cincinnati. The following season, the Reds won the World Series, giving him the first of his five championships.
The Phillies were 29-50. Left-hander Larry McWilliams held Cincinnati to two runs over 7⅔ innings. With John Kruk watching on television while recovering from arthroscopic knee surgery, Dwayne Murphy’s fourth-inning two-run single provided all of their offense through nine.
The game remained tied at 2 in the bottom of the 10th at Veterans Stadium. Phillies speedy infielder Steve Jeltz singled and advanced to second before Lenny Dykstra sent a ball toward right field.
“It was wet,” O’Neill said of the Vet’s slick conditions. “Dykstra hits me a ball. I come in, I bobble it. I bobble it. I think the game is over.”
Then came the unthinkable.
“I just, out of frustration, kicked the ball,” the five-time All-Star said. “It just so happened that the ball went completely straight, like a field goal, to Todd Benzinger.”
Jeltz had slipped rounding third, allowing Phillies third base coach Larry Bowa to hold him. O’Neill never saw it. Benzinger, Cincinnati’s first baseman, did not even realize his right fielder had punted the ball to him.
The kick kept the game tied.
For one pitch.
John Franco issued a four-pitch intentional walk to Tom Herr. His next pitch, to Von Hayes, got away. Jeltz scored and the Phillies won.
O’Neill returned to the dugout wondering what might come next.
“I was thinking, ‘You’ve got to be kidding me, what I just did,’” he said. “My best friend on the team at that time was Chris Sabo, and I just sat on the bench … thinking, ‘My God, they’re gonna send me down to Triple A. You can’t do stuff like this.’”
Sabo had watched Bowa erupt from the opposite dugout.
“He just kept repeating, Larry Bowa was going crazy, saying, ‘Did you see what happened? O’Neill kicked the ball. He kicked the ball,’” O’Neill said. “Sabes was sort of laughing about it.”
NBC Sports Philadelphia’s Ben Davis was 12 years old and sitting down the right-field line, near where the Vet curved toward the ball girl. Davis, who grew up in nearby Aston and later reached the majors himself, was a diehard Phillies fan.
The play unfolded directly in front of him.
“We couldn’t have had a better seat in the house for it,” Davis said. “He bobbled it, and then all of a sudden he kicks it. We’re like, wait a minute. He didn’t throw that. He kicked it.”
O’Neill had some experience. He was a field goal kicker and punter in high school, though he kicked straight on instead of soccer style.
Discussing the moment conjured memories of two Oakland Raiders Hall of Famers: punter Ray Guy and placekicker George Blanda. More than three decades later, O’Neill even remembered his cleats.
“I think they were Pony, actually,” O’Neill said.
Three-time World Cup champion, and soccer god, Pelé wore Pony while playing for the New York Cosmos in the mid-1970s.
O’Neill’s kick was not planned. That made the result harder to believe.
“It wasn’t premeditated,” O’Neill said. “It wasn’t like, ‘I’ve got to get rid of the ball, so I’ll kick it.’ It was out of frustration. But it happened to go straight.”
That remains the most improbable part for Davis.
“Kicking a baseball is not like kicking a soccer ball,” he said. “It could go off the side of your foot, and get angled. You could have kicked it anywhere, but the fact that he kicked it right to the cutoff man just blew our minds.”
“It was like the perfect kick,” Davis said.
O’Neill eventually watched the replay. The voice that stayed with him belonged to Johnny Bench on Cincinnati’s broadcast.
“‘All of my life, I have never seen a play like this in the major leagues,’” O’Neill said, recalling Bench’s call. “‘And he kicked the ball.’”
Davis has not seen another one.
“Never,” Davis said. “Absolutely never. I don’t know if I ever will. That was a one and done for me. That was one and only.”
O’Neill’s youngest daughter, Allie, does not remember watching him play. She knows the kick.
“She sees the bloopers every year, and it makes the list every single year,” O’Neill said, laughing.
There’s no crying in baseball. Apparently, kicking is another matter.
His Baseball-Reference page still lists him as “Bats: Left • Throws: Left • Kicks: Left.”