While I appreciate LNP | LancasterOnline’s commitment to publishing a range of viewpoints, it is jarring to read an editorial supporting local public schools one week (“Public school enrollments may be declining in Lancaster County, but we still believe in public education,” Aug. 8) and then encounter a Perspective section front-page column by a lawyer whose organization is essentially lobbying to privatize public education (“Tax credit programs extend school choice and enable kids to attend better schools,” Aug. 15).

I believe that readers should approach commentary from the Commonwealth Foundation with skepticism. Its advocates frame their agenda in terms of educational “choice,” promoting tax credits and school vouchers as ways to expand access to educational excellence for low-income students. Yet the policies they champion seemingly do not align with that stated goal.

If educational equity were truly the priority, organizations such as the Commonwealth Foundation would support legislation such as state Rep. Nikki Rivera’s House Bill 2632. The bill would strengthen reporting requirements and tighten income eligibility standards for tuition tax credit programs intended to help students in under-resourced school districts, including the School District of Lancaster.

Pennsylvania currently diverts hundreds of millions of dollars in taxpayer-supported tax credits to subsidize private school tuition. Families earning up to $157,000 annually can qualify for assistance. Rep. Rivera’s bill seeks to ensure these benefits reach the families they were designed to serve and provides greater transparency about who receives them.

My view is simple: If we invested our resources and commitment into local public schools governed by locally elected school boards, all of our communities and children would be better served. Until then, we should be honest about privatization efforts and recognize these columns as advocacy for a political agenda — not objective educational policy analysis.

Susan Knoll

Lancaster city

Success! An email has been sent to with a link to confirm list signup.

Error! There was an error processing your request.