The state Superior Court ruled a Maryland man who scammed a Clarks Summit woman to be re-sentenced.

In a decision issued last week, a three-judge panel ordered a new sentencing hearing for Luis Alberto Polanco-Guzman, 36, of Gambrills, Maryland.

Lackawanna County detectives charged Polanco-Guzman in 2024 with felony theft, criminal use of a communication facility and dealing in proceeds of unlawful activity. The charges stemmed from an investigation conducted by detectives and the Clarks Summit Police Department, where they determined he scammed a then-80 year old borough woman out of nearly $42,000, claiming it helped her grandson, according to authorities. He arranged for a Lyft ride to collect the money, and was subsequently arrested and charged.

Lackawanna County Judge Michael Barrasse sentenced Polanco-Guzman last year to between 30 and 60 months in prison and six years of probation on counts of theft by deception and criminal use of a communication facility. He also ordered Polanco-Guzman to to pay the victim $36,500 in restitution, and $5,000 to the victim’s compensation fund.

During the trial, the prosecutors offered Polanco-Guzman a guilty plea to one count each of theft by deception and criminal use of a communication facility, with $20,000 in restitution to the victim, in exchange for dropping the remaining charges. Prosecutors further offered to drop the theft charge if he offered an additional $16,500 to the victim by the time of his sentencing. However, if Polanco-Guzman failed to fulfill those requirements, prosecutors could revoke the offer. Polanco-Guzman agreed to it.

During sentencing, prosecutors said he failed to pay restitution to the victim and while they didn’t revoke the offer, they did not drop the theft charge. The court also didn’t state that Polanco-Guzman was eligible for Recidivism Risk Reduction Incentive, a state program that reduces a nonviolent offender’s minimum sentence if they complete recommended programs and maintained good conduct.

Two weeks after after Barrasse sentenced Polanco-Guzman, Ryan Barrett, the attorney representing Polanco-Guzman, and Polanco-Guzman himself filed separate post-sentence motions, but only Polanco-Guzman’s motion was included in the court record and it was denied. Barrett later withdrew as Polanco-Guzman’s attorney, and the court appointed Donna DeVita as his attorney and told her to file a statement of errors. She later asked to withdraw without filing the required statement and the court appointed Jordan Leonard, who filed a statement of errors and argued, among other things, that the court failed to decide if the appellant was eligible for the incentive at sentencing. Leonard requested to withdraw from the case.

The court later ruled Polanco-Guzman was eligible for the incentive and modified the sentencing order to 22 1/2 months in prison without informing Polanco-Guzman or his attorney.

The judges denied Leonard’s application to withdraw, vacated the sentence and ordered a new sentencing hearing in Lackawanna County court.