European Aquatics has released the Jury of Appeal’s decisions disqualifying Hungarian Open-Water swimmers Bettina Fabian and David Bethlehem at the Open Water Swimming Cup in Razanac, Croatia.
The Jury of Appeal’s decision comes after several comments criticized the organization’s disqualifications.
The core argument in both cases comes down to the cap they were wearing. The event rules require a specific cap with the EPAM sponsor logo.
In Bethlehem’s case, the decision states that he wore the correct cap but the wrong way, with the sponsor logo on the wrong side. It also mentions that a technical delegate told him to fix it at the starting platform before the race began; he was one of four to wear the cap incorrectly, while the other three complied and fixed it.
In an Instagram post from Bethlehem today, he said an official gave him a cap, and he was wearing it correctly, yet he still received a DQ after the race. He said this was not mentioned in the statement from European Aquatics.
The final decision was ultimately upheld due to Bethlehem’s “failure to follow the explicit instructions of the Technical Delegate before
the start”
In the name of Integrity, Transparency and Good Governance, values European Aquatics are so proud of, check out this photo of me finishing strong with a fellow swimmer (who is a good friend of mine). We wore caps with the same configuration, NOC logo on the left, sponsor logo on the right. I got a DSQ, he didn’t. It’s not his fault, both of us did a great job. There was also a big difference: I got this cap from an EA Technical Official. This is something you won’t read in EA’s statement published today.
@euroaquatics
For Fabian, the decision claims that her red cap was not compliant, adding that the Clerk of Course and two other assistants told her it did not meet the competition’s regulations.
Per the Jury of Appeal, she was offered a blank cap with the EPAM logo and was given a choice to either write her country’s letters on the blank side herself or have the Clerk of Course do it for her. In response, Fabian wrote it herself, but still wore the red cap, stepped onto the starting platform, started the race, and was disqualified after finishing 2nd overall.
Fabian also shared her frustrations on Instagram, posting a long message about the matter and tagging only European Aquatics.
Her message reads:
I don’t usually speak publicly about decisions made after races, but what happened today is simply unacceptable.
I raced the 10 km European Aquatics Open Water Cup and finished 2nd.
During registration, I personally presented my Hungarian racing cap to the officials. They checked it, told me it was okay and allowed me to continue the registration process.
I was never told that my cap was not allowed.
I was never given a replacement cap.
I was never asked to write my nationality on another cap.
And I obviously never refused to wear one.
If I had actually been given a compliant replacement cap, OF COURSE I would have worn it. Why would I intentionally risk disqualification over a swimming cap?
Breaking the rules was never my intention.
Instead, I was allowed to start the race and swim the entire 10 km.
Apparently, I received a red card during the third lap. I genuinely did not see or register it.
I was leading the race, swimming alone with nobody around me, and I received no signal that I actually noticed or understood telling me that I had to stop racing.
So I continued.
I raced the full 10 km and crossed the finish line in second place.
Afterwards, I was disqualified because of the сар.
We immediately submitted a protest. It was rejected based on the claim that during registration I had allegedly been informed that my cap was incorrect, had been given another cap, and had refused to use it.
This did not happen.
I told the Chief Referee repeatedly that this conversation NEVER took place. Yet my protest was rejected based on exactly this version of events.
From my perspective, the staff’s version of events was simply accepted over mine, and I am the one paying the price for it.
I can accept losing.
I can accept being beaten.
I can accept a penalty when I knowingly or clearly break a rule.
But I cannot accept being allowed to start and race 10 km after my cap was checked, receiving no replacement cap, and then having my result taken away. Followed by my protest being rejected based on a conversation and a refusal that I know never happened.
Athletes deserve fairness.
Athletes deserve accountability.
And athletes deserve the truth.
I know exactly what happened at that registration, and I will stand by it.
Shame on you, European Aquatics
Both cases stated that the appeals were rejected due to procedural inadmissibility, both saying that their protests were not submitted within the mandatory 30-minute timeframe following the conclusion of the race, and that both protests were delivered by the athletes themselves, rather than the authorized “Team Leader,” which violates the formal protest procedures.