A concert at a Dickson City venue fell apart after a social media debate over using AI turned nasty.

“Oh man, this was a doozy,” said Ken Stucker, co-owner of Union Vapors 570. The vape shop and music venue was recently named venue of the year at the Steamtown Music Awards.

Instead of hosting metal and alternative acts Slapjaw, Purple Lung, DOUR, and Shodemon, Stucker is wondering how far an anti-AI policy for the venue should go.

The bands canceled after a debate that didn’t initially involve Union Vapors 570, he said. The Scranton-area band Slapjaw posted what Stucker called an AI image on its own social media to promote the show, which was scheduled for Sept. 25.

A back-and-forth between AI critics in the comments and a representative of Slapjaw turned into “bullying,” Stucker said. Union Vapors 570 was tagged in the posts. Stucker ended up responding to a slew of messages, he said.

Between the bad blood on social media and discomfort with AI, all the bands eventually dropped out, he said.

Slapjaw could not be reached for comment and the original posts appear to have been deleted. Stucker said he doesn’t have a copy.

When the cancellation was announced, the debate blew up again on the venue’s social media, with a mix of views on AI and disappointment that the show was canceled.

“I’d rather see event details scrawled out on (a) napkin with ketchup stains on it than the absolute trash that is AI event fliers,” one commenter wrote.

Others noted the irony of using social media to complain about the latest tech developments and another suggested AI opponents could become Amish.

“I am saddened that this show had to be canceled,” Stucker said. “I’m sorry to each of the bands. I know that they were all excited about the show. I’m sorry for the fans, because in the course of that argument that was led by that one band, several people had their feelings hurt. And while none of the bands that play at our venue work directly for us, we do understand that there’s a very real way in which they represent us.”

Union Vapors 570 doesn’t post AI materials but has not addressed what acts do on their own, Stucker said. “We wanted to let people kind of do what people wanted to do,” he said.

Now he’s formulating a written policy. Acts that want to perform there cannot use AI to promote a Union Vapors 570 gig, even on their own social media or other advertisements. He’s unclear how far the ban will extend. What about other apps and digital tools? “That’s where the conversation gets really interesting,” he said. “Because then we’re talking about something that isn’t necessarily producing something completely with AI, but it uses AI-powered tools to accomplish certain effects.”

The anti-AI attitude is part of “an unwritten code of conduct that kind of exists in the larger music scene,” he said. Acts that argue that AI is necessary should remember that musicians did just fine without it until now, he said.

“When you look at the punk shows of the ’80s and ’90s, these were things that were meant to be done, you know, very affordably, but still authentically.”

In a social media post, Purple Lung, a regional doom metal band, stressed the importance of human creativity. “Though we didn’t drop out specifically due to the use of generative AI, I’d like to make a point in saying that we are artists who belong to an ecosystem of other artists,” the post said.

The other three acts remain welcome at Union Vapors 570, Stucker said. A future date with Slapjaw would be subject to a conversation between the band and the venue, he said.