By Joseph E. Welsh
There is an old saying that a skillful prosecutor could persuade a grand jury to indict even a ham sandwich.
Leaving aside the advisability of grand juries in the criminal justice system, the recently released Northampton County investigating grand jury report on Gracedale raises serious questions about the advisability of investigating grand juries developing public policy.
Simply put, is a grand jury the right institution to formulate public policy for a large and extraordinarily complicated nursing home? The answer clearly is no.
At the outset it is important to note that being a juror, on either a grand or a petit jury is not easy, and those who serve this high civic duty deserve our praise. Just look at the glimpse behind the veil of secrecy provided by the Lindsay Clancy trial to see the emotionally grueling process of deliberations. In fact, the Criminal Justice Committee of the Pennsylvania Interbranch Commission on Fairness and Equity, on which I serve, has been actively engaged in promoting a juror mental health program.
But investigating what went wrong and deciding what our county should do about it are two very different jobs. A county-owned skilled nursing facility is an enormously complicated institution.
Good policy development requires knowledge and experience. It requires consideration of alternatives, costs and unintended consequences. It requires hearing competing viewpoints and testing assumptions. And ultimately, in a democracy, it requires public decisions by officials who must answer to the voters. That is not how a grand jury works.
Grand juries meet in secret. Prosecutors determine what evidence they hear and which witnesses appear before them. Competing evidence and alternative explanations are not presented. Ironically, advocates who shout for more transparency hail the grand jury report, which was created entirely in secrecy.
The report actually highlights the problem. The grand jury acknowledges that it did not have access to individual residents’ medical records and it was impossible for it to determine the extent of patient safety problems during the period it examined. Yet, it makes policy recommendations on that admittedly flawed record.
For example, the report suggests reducing agency nursing staff. This may be a good idea, but that isn’t the point. The question is how we determine whether they are the best ideas. This recommendation sounds simple until someone actually has to do it.
County Executive Tara Zrinski, who took office only this year, has been confronting precisely that question as part of a much broader restructuring of Gracedale.
I attended the recent County Council meeting at which Zrinski proposed restructuring compensation for 27 nursing supervisor positions. Agency supervisors told her they would consider becoming county employees if county compensation were competitive.
But, what compensation would attract qualified nurses? What would it cost? How does that compare with what taxpayers are already paying staffing agencies? How do we retain those employees? How quickly can the transition occur without jeopardizing resident care?
Zrinski developed a specific policy proposal intended to answer those questions. County Council unanimously approved it in a public meeting.
That is what real policy-making looks like. It can be messy, and reasonable people can disagree. But alternatives are considered, costs are examined, elected officials debate them publicly and those officials can be held accountable for the results. None of that is present in a grand jury.
This concern is nothing new. In 2019, a majority of legal scholars appointed to a task force by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court recommended eliminating grand jury reports altogether. For a more detailed analysis of why grand juries are inappropriate for administrative policy development, see “Restoring Legitimacy: The Grand Jury as the Prosecutor’s Administrative Agency” in a 2017 Harvard Law Review.
The grand jury was largely examining conditions at Gracedale before this year. Zrinski took office in January. Her administration has already created a continuum of care structure, appointed professional leadership, begun addressing reliance on agency staff, proposed changes involving quality assurance and security, and started planning for Gracedale’s long-term physical and financial future.
Those efforts, of course, will be subject to the transparency of the administrative and legislative process, not conducted in the secrecy of the grand jury room. County Council, residents, families, employees, taxpayers and the media need to be part of that process.
The problems at Gracedale are long-standing and serious. Complex solutions must be developed between the administration and council in the sunshine of the policy development process.
While one might study a ham sandwich in secret, fixing Gracedale will require all of our policymakers working together, developing policy which reflects all perspectives, not just those spoon-fed to them from one perspective.
This is a contributed opinion column. Joseph E. Welsh is a resident of East Allen Township. The views expressed in this piece are those of its individual author(s), and should not be interpreted as reflecting the views of this publication. For more details on commentaries, read our guide to guest opinions at mcall.com/opinion.