The other parties to a stipulated court order stemming from Lackawanna County’s decadeslong failure to reassess “do not consent” to delaying implementation of new property values calculated during the county’s first comprehensive reassessment since 1968, their attorney said in a letter Wednesday.

It comes after an attorney for the county sent Monday correspondence seeking a one-year delay in implementing the new assessments, something the county must do by Jan. 1, 2026 under the court order. The county agreed to the order’s terms in 2022, postponing further action in a civil lawsuit seeking to compel a reassessment on the basis of tax fairness.

Attorney Marielle Macher, the executive director of the nonprofit Community Justice Project who represents plaintiffs Brian Skotch and Ronald Monroe in that case, reiterated in her response letter Wednesday that the county’s new assessments will result in a much fairer distribution of the tax burden. The county’s “current assessment scheme is deeply unequal and regressive, with owners of lower-value properties paying far more than their fair share,” she wrote.

Macher also rejected the notion that the failure to include old assessed values on mailed reassessment notices county property owners received earlier this year amounts to a fatal defect. It’s an issue attorney John Dean, representing Lackawanna County, raised in his Monday letter seeking the one-year extension.

“Accordingly, we do not consent to delaying implementation of the reassessed values, and we expect the reassessed values to be certified by November 15, 2025,” Macher wrote.

Her clients’ unwillingness to delay the reassessment’s implementation to 2027 makes more dubious the prospect of a reassessment pause Republican Commissioner Chris Chermak and certain others have spent months calling for. The stipulated court order states that the county “shall fully complete the Reassessment and implement the final new assessed values for use in all real property taxation in Lackawanna County no later than January 1, 2026.”

The county would be “in blatant violation” of the order if it tried to unilaterally change that timeline and “we would have no choice but to move to enforce the court order,” Macher wrote in an email Oct. 24.

Efforts to reach Chermak and Democratic Commissioner Brenda Sacco were not immediately successful.

But Democratic Commissioner Bill Gaughan, who has repeatedly criticized the notion the county can or should delay the reassessment, said certifying the new assessed valuations is “common sense.”

“If Commissioner Chermak and Sacco screw this thing up it’s going to cost the taxpayers at least $2.5 million next year, which we don’t have, and that is horrific public policy,” he said.

The $2.5 million estimate of what delaying the reassessment might cost comes from a document an official from Tyler Technologies, the firm that conducted the reassessment, recently sent to Gaughan, who shared it Monday. The deadline for the county Assessor’s Office to certify the new values for use next year is Saturday.

Check back for updates.