Ohio company recalls tomato soup sold in Pennsylvania due to allergen risk

An Ohio company has recalled all lots of its tomato basil soup because it contains an allergen that is not noted on the label.

Lil’ Turtles recalled 17-ounce glass jars of Grandma Belle’s Tomato Basil Soup for misbranding because the milk allergen is not declared on the label. People with a sensitivity to or who are allergic to milk could have an allergic reaction if they eat the soup.

The soup was distributed from Sept. 23 to Dec. 3, 2025, at retail stores in 14 states include these in Pennsylvania:

Indian Trail Country Market, ElizabethvilleBurger Farms, DrumsPaul’s Country Market, Waynesboro

According to an announcement with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, the problem was discovered during a routine inspection by the Ohio Department of Agriculture.

There have been no reports of illness involving the soup.

The soup also was sold at these stores:

Illinois – Countryside Variety, BuncombeIndiana – Dented Can, Goshen; and Sommher’s Bakery, GosportIowa – Golden Delight Bakery, KalonaKansas – Jet Produce, LeavenworthKentucky – Creekside Pantry, LondonMinnesota – Cherry Grove Market, BrowervilleMississippi – 45 Flea Market, MeridianMissouri – Sunnyside Market, El DoradoNew York – The Olde Bat Factory, Hancock; Shadyview Farm, Rushville; Beef and Butter Company, Rochester; Hymers Farm Market, Delhi; and Troyers Country Store, CanastotaOhio – Baltic Meats, Baltic; Trailside Deli, Millersburg; Randles Cheese, Millersburg; Wesley Miller, Sugarcreek; Bambi Farm Market, Orient; Baker Florist, Dover; Jungle Jim, Cincinnati; and Becks Market, GreenvilleOklahoma – Amish Cheesehouse, Chouteau; and Martins House Country Store, DavisUtah – Applecreek Willard, WillardWisconsin – Hecks Farm Market, Arena

Consumers should contact Lil’ Turtles for a replacement pack. For more information, call Josh Coblentz at 330-897-6400.