Alex Perry, Columbus Dispatch
Thu, January 15, 2026 at 3:03 PM UTC
Want to own a private island in Ohio? One Lake Erie property has hit the market, and it can all be yours — for $5 million.
Once owned by President Rutherford B. Hayes, Mouse Island spans about seven acres of wooded land just off the coast of Catawba Island in Port Clinton (about an hour East of Toledo), according to the property listing. Zoned for private use, the property is still within reach of attractions such as Cedar Point and the Lake Erie Islands.
Here’s what to know.
Mouse Island is for sale, with an asking price of $5 million.
Private island in Lake Erie once owned by former president for sale for $5 million
Mouse Island offers privacy with mature trees, rocky shorelines and opportunities for custom development or simply going off‑the‑grid and features 360-degree lake views. “Ideal for nature lovers, boaters, and those seeking an exclusive escape, the island is accessible by private boat and sits just minutes from the mainland,” the listing reads.
Based on the listing’s estimate, a 30‑year fixed mortgage at an average rate of 6.025% would result in a monthly payment of about $25,373.
President Rutherford B. Hayes’ cottage on Mouse Island. The island is for sale, with an asking price of $5 million. The people pictured are unknown. The cottage no longer exists.
Mouse Island, formerly owned by President Rutherford B. Hayes, is for sale with an asking price of $5 million. The Rutherford cottage no longer exists.
The property has been on Realtor.com since July 2025.
In line with Mouse Island’s exclusivity, visitors must have approval to approach the island. While there are no upcoming open houses, interested buyers can request a private showing through the site.
President Rutherford B. Hayes’ cottage on Mouse Island. The island is for sale, with an asking price of $5 million. The people pictured are unknown. The cottage no longer exists.
This article originally appeared on The Columbus Dispatch: Ohio private island with presidential past hits market for $5 million