Gavel and scales
DALLAS—A federal judge in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas last week blocked portions of HB 1696, the 2023 Texas law that restricted how managed vision care plans communicate price and provider participation information to members. Judge James Wesley Hendrix ruled that key provisions of the statute violated the First Amendment by barring vision plans from informing patients about participating providers who offer lower cost services or products. The opinion said the law would have “forced consumers to remain ‘misled or uninformed for their own protection,’” the court said in rendering its decision.

The lawsuit, filed in 2023, was brought by a coalition that included the Healthy Vision Association, the National Association of Vision Care Plans (NAVCP), VSP Insurance Company and Visionworks. The plaintiffs said HB 1696 would stop plans from telling members about lower cost options and participating providers, and that would reduce transparency and consumer choice. VMAIL reported at the time of the original complaint that plaintiffs said the statute “stops dead in its tracks a market-based mechanism for decreasing the cost of vision care” by restricting communications to members.

When the suit was filed, the Healthy Vision Association said the law “imposes unconstitutional restraint on the right of managed vision care companies to communicate important health care information to insured patients, including how to maximize their benefits through specific providers.” The association framed the challenge as protecting consumers’ right to receive information that helps them make informed, cost conscious decisions.

Michael Guyette, president and CEO of VSP Vision, called the court’s decision “a resounding win for Texans,” saying the ruling “empowers individuals to access affordable, high-quality eyecare and eyewear in a destination that best suits their needs.” The company said HB 1696 would have prevented plans from informing members about participating providers who offer more affordable services or products, thereby limiting consumer value and choice.

The Alliance for Affordable Vision Care (AAVC), a coalition of plan and consumer oriented groups, also praised the ruling. The AAVC said keeping communication channels open preserves patients’ access to “clear, accurate information about their vision coverage and lower cost care options.” 

Rich Schindehette, president of the Healthy Vision Association and an AAVC member, said, “Vision care patients deserve straightforward, factual information about how to use their vision benefits. When families have access to information about all their options, they can make choices that benefit their health and finances.”

Supporters of HB 1696—including the Texas Optometric Association (TOA) and the American Optometric Association (AOA)—say the law was intended to curb what they call anti competitive and vertically integrated practices by some vision benefit managers. They say the statute was designed to stop tactics such as steering patients to plan owned retailers, tiering providers based on product purchases or discounts, imposing unfair chargebacks, requiring unrelated patient data on claims, and using audit extrapolation. Those supporters argue such practices can limit provider independence and harm patient choice.

“Texas optometrists, who provide the majority of primary eyecare in the state, intervened in the lawsuit alongside the State of Texas to defend HB 1696,” the TOA told VMAIL. “We believe the statute’s restrictions on conduct by VBMs (Vision Benefits Managers) were narrowly tailored to prevent deceptive steering and protect vulnerable consumers, consistent with the state’s authority to regulate insurance and health care markets for the public good.” 

The TOA expressed it respectfully disagrees with the federal court’s latest decision, calling it a setback for Texas patients and access to vision care. In a statement provided to VMAIL, it said, “While we respect the judicial process, this ruling undermines Texas’ efforts to curb monopolistic behaviors in the vision benefits industry that drive up costs, limit provider networks, and erode patient choice and access. The TOA remains committed to advocating for policies that put patients and independent providers first.” 

“It seems the vision benefit middleman industry is pointing to a temporary reprieve through the courts for corrupt and thoroughly anti-patient, ‘steering and tiering,’ tactics, a result of their two years of legal warfare targeting the Texas Department of Insurance and legislature, the TOA, and a provision of the state’s comprehensive 2023 VBM reform law,” Jacquie Bowen, OD, AOA president, told VMAIL. “What they refuse to discuss is resolving patient and doctor complaints and the growing nationwide momentum for VBM accountability.”

The TOA noted that it will continue working with the Texas legislature, the attorney general’s office, and its partners to “explore all available options to restore and strengthen protections for Texas consumers and doctors of optometry.”