Second grade teacher Sumaya Ali talks to students last year at Iman Academy Southwest in Houston. A recent lawsuit states that “not a single accredited Islamic private school has been approved” for Texas’ new voucher program.
Raquel Natalicchio/Staff photographer
On March 1, a Houston parent sued Texas officials, alleging that the state is excluding Islamic schools from its new voucher program, even as hundreds of other private schools — including many Christian schools — are approved. The complaint states that “not a single accredited Islamic private school has been approved.” This should concern every Texan, regardless of religious or political belief.
If the state can sideline Islamic schools today, it could sideline certain Christian schools tomorrow if a doctrine falls out of political favor — or even secular schools that teach ideas disfavored by those in power. That is not educational freedom but rather state interference in private education.
Article continues below this ad
For the record, I strongly oppose vouchers. Research and history show these programs expand quickly, often reproduce exclusion, and rarely deliver consistent academic gains. But if Texas has a voucher law, constitutional protections — like the Free Exercise Clause and Equal Protection Clause — must apply equally to everyone, regardless of faith or viewpoint.
What is Texas running now? In 2025, lawmakers passed Senate Bill 2, creating a school voucher program with $1 billion in funding, overseen by the Comptroller’s office. Families can apply for a voucher through March 17. Those who receive a voucher typically get about $10,500 per student.
How did exclusion enter the picture? In December, Acting Comptroller Kelly Hancock asked Attorney General Ken Paxton whether he could block schools with supposed ties to entities Texas labels “foreign terrorist organizations.” In January, Paxton issued an opinion saying the comptroller may exclude schools under an “other relevant law” clause — but the opinion leaves case‑by‑case decisions to the comptroller.
ALSO READ: I teach at a Muslim school. Our students deserve access to vouchers
Article continues below this ad
In the same period, Gov. Greg Abbott designated the Council on American‑Islamic Relations a terrorist organization — a designation CAIR is challenging in federal court. CAIR is not designated as a terrorist organization by the U.S. government.
The result is that Muslim families are being denied a benefit Texas promised to all parents. If the state can blacklist schools based on broad or speculative “ties,” or conflate mainstream Muslim civic life with extremism, it risks violating core constitutional principles — precisely what the Houston lawsuit against Paxton, Hancock and Education Commissioner Mike Morath argues. Texans of all beliefs should be wary of this kind of government overreach.
These choices also echo the history of school vouchers. As an education researcher who has studied vouchers for years, my colleagues and I have documented how the first wave of vouchers during the Jim Crow era helped preserve racial segregation. Later waves promised free-market solutions but often rewarded schools that could screen students or pass along hidden costs.
Over 150 years, there is little evidence that voucher markets reliably deliver improved academic achievement outcomes for families — and plenty of evidence that vulnerable groups face exclusion and discrimination.
Article continues below this ad
RELATED: Texas’ voucher law doesn’t pick and choose religions. Neither should state officials.
Even if you support vouchers in principle or plan on using a voucher this upcoming school year, consider what happens when the political winds shift. Today’s rationale targets Islamic private schools, but tomorrow it could target particular Christian teachings, Jewish schools or secular curricula on topics like race, gender or civic engagement. If the state can weaponize private school eligibility criteria, “choice” becomes conditional and every family’s freedom is at risk.
There is a straightforward fix. If Texas is determined to have what it calls the largest day-one voucher program in the nation, the comptroller must apply clear, neutral criteria to every school — Islamic, Christian, Jewish and secular — based on documented, school-specific findings. All relevant criteria, evidence and decisions for including or excluding an accredited private school should be made public.
This would effectively stop substituting insinuation for investigation.
Article continues below this ad
Many voucher supporters call these programs civil rights for parents, including U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz, yet most have been quiet as Muslim families are denied a public benefit. Every Texan should remember that when rights can be revoked for one faith, or one curriculum, all of our rights are at risk.
Texas created this market. Now state leaders must prove that it works — and that it is truly fair for all families.
David DeMatthews is a professor of education in the Department of Educational Leadership and Policy at the University of Texas. He is expressing his views as a private citizen.
Article continues below this ad