A lawsuit filed this week by the Save Our Springs Alliance challenges the Central Texas Regional Mobility Authority’s refusal to release public comments on its proposed expansion of MoPac, a dispute that raises questions about transparency as the public comment period enters its final days.
The suit in Travis County District Court alleges that CTRMA violated the Texas Public Information Act by withholding comments submitted during the agency’s review of the proposed 8.8-mile MoPac South expansion from Enfield Road to Slaughter Lane. The group is seeking a court order to immediately release the comments. It has requested that an expedited hearing be held before the May 3 end to the project’s public comment period.
Save Our Springs Executive Director Bill Bunch said the group wants a hearing right away, though a judge has not yet agreed to expedite the case.
Bill Bunch
“We’re seeking an immediate hearing on the merits next week,” Bunch said after a CTRMA board meeting on Wednesday.
CTRMA has asked the Texas Attorney General to let it withhold the comments from Save Our Springs, arguing that the comments are internal deliberations that should not be released until the environmental review is complete. Austin Free Press also has requested public comments on the project
Save Our Springs counters that public comments are not internal deliberations, and that withholding public comments during the comment period limits meaningful public participation.
“The public comments that are from the public in an official public process is clearly public information under the Texas Public Information Act,” Bunch told the CTRMA board members on Wednesday.
He urged the board to direct staff to release the comments or agree to a prompt court hearing. Bunch also asked the board to extend the comment period due to the volume of supporting documents..
“They have to evaluate and compile those documents and respond to the points raised,” he said. “We have no idea how long they’ll take with that, but likely it’ll be at least a few months.”
Public information experts in the media and legal professions previously told Austin Free Press that CTRMA’s attempts to keep public comments confidential are “absurd.”
The proposed expansion crosses the Edwards Aquifer Recharge Zone.
Credit: Lindsey Holmes
At its Wednesday meeting the CTRMA board denied the request to extend the public comment period and took no action on the lawsuit or the underlying MoPac-expansion project.
Representatives of the Austin Chamber of Commerce, Westlake Chamber of Commerce, and City of Rollingwood endorsed the expansion project at the board meeting, saying it will bring economic and mobility benefits.
Other speakers raised concerns about environmental impacts, public health risks, and the review process.
Bobby Levinski
Save Our Spring attorney Bobby Levinski told the board that elected officials from the City of Austin and Travis County have already called for a full environmental impact statement, arguing the agency should “recognize the significant impacts” of the project on surrounding communities.
CTRMA declined to comment directly on the lawsuit. “The Mobility Authority does not comment on pending litigation,” it said in a written statement. “We will reiterate that the integrity of the (National Environmental Policy Act) process is of utmost importance to the Mobility Authority. Our course of action here is to avoid jeopardizing that process.”
Disclosure: Bill Bunch sits on the Austin Free Press advisory board.
Chad Swiatecki is a 30-year journalist who relocated to Austin from his home state of Michigan in 2008. He most enjoys covering the intersection of arts, business and local/state politics. He has written for Rolling Stone, Spin, New York Daily News, Texas Monthly, Austin Monitor, Austin Business Journal, Austin American-Statesman and many other regional and national outlets.