In a federal lawsuit filed May 1 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, Buc-ee’s alleges that Teddy’s Market built its brand by closely copying the company’s look, from its cartoon animal mascot to its overall visual identity. The case is the latest in a long line of legal battles for Buc-ee’s, which has repeatedly gone after other businesses it claims are borrowing too heavily from its signature beaver brand.
According to the complaint obtained by MySA, Buc-ee’s claims Teddy’s created a “confusingly similar brand centered around a smiling, hat-wearing animal with white eye highlights, a black nose, a visible pink tongue and lighter coloring around its mouth, all design elements the company says mirror its well-known beaver logo.
The lawsuit reviewed by MySA also points to similarities in how the logos are presented, including bold outlines and the use of a geometric shape with red accents surrounding the character. Buc-ee’s argues these shared features, combined with nearly identical services, could easily mislead customers, especially drivers spotting signage from the highway.
Beyond the visuals, Buc-ee’s takes issue with the name itself. The complaint notes that “Buc-ee’s” and “Teddy’s” are both two-syllable, six-letter possessive names ending in an “eez” sound, which the company argues increases the likelihood of consumer confusion. The legal dispute comes as Teddy’s rapidly expands in north Georgia. The company opened stores in Canton in November 2024 and Ball Ground in January 2025, both near Buc-ee’s location in Calhoun. A third store is already in the works in Decatur along the same highway corridor.
According to reports by CBS Atlanta, Teddy’s owner, Karan Ahuja, has disputed the allegations but declined to comment further due to the ongoing litigation. Buc-ee’s alleges the proximity is no coincidence and argues the branding was intentionally designed to capitalize on its popularity. The Texas-based chain, founded in 1982, now operates more than 50 locations across a dozen states and says its brand has become widely recognizable among travelers.
In the lawsuit, Buc-ee’s is asking the court to order Teddy’s to stop using its current branding, destroy any infringing materials and hand over profits tied to the disputed identity. The company is also seeking triple damages and wants federal trademark officials to reject Teddy’s pending trademark applications.
A recent court filing shows the case has already hit a minor procedural snag. On Thursday, May 7, the court issued a notice of deficiency stating Buc-ee’s failed to properly file a required AO Form 120, which must be submitted in trademark cases. The company has been directed to complete and refile the form in accordance with local court rules.
MySA reached out to Buc-ee’s and Teddy’s Market for comment.