Alan Stalcup, left, and his team are seen on the GVA Property Management website. Zachary Richards, center.

Alan Stalcup, left, and his team are seen on the GVA Property Management website. Zachary Richards, center.

GVA Property Management

An Austin real estate investor is claiming victory in a dispute stemming from accusations that he fraudulently siphoned off more than $100 million in funds others invested in his company and misstated its financial position.

Alan Stalcup — once among the largest landlords in the nation — has long said he committed no fraud and, as proof, now is pointing to a new report from an expert witness and a private settlement with another investor who had made similar allegations.

Article continues below this ad

Lawsuits against Alan Stalcup and his empire have not ceased, with another filed in early April in Indiana stating GVA and Stalcup had violated that state’s securities laws by making material misstatements and failing to include disclaimers and descriptions of risk. 

Stalcup called the new claims “unfounded,” describing the lawsuit as an attempt by investors to shirk the consequences of their own business decisions.

He also lost an $8 million case in New York, where he was being sued by commercial real estate lender Starwood Property Mortgage over a bridge loan. Starwood also won another civil suit against Stalcup that could be worth as much as $20 million. In a third case, Starwood says it is owed $83 million from loans to GVA that Stalcup personally guaranteed. 

The embattled businessman has been fighting to regain control of the narrative around his company, GVA Property Management, which once had more than 40,000 apartments across nine states. Since 2023, though, its holdings have fallen to about 5,000 units through foreclosures and sales, costing Stalcup and his investors hundreds of millions of dollars.

FROM FEBRUARY: Embattled Austin real estate titan Alan Stalcup lashes out at fraud accusers, defends actions at GVA

He and the company have been sued multiple times over the losses by investors alleging fraud. One court filing said the Securities and Exchange Commission had subpoenaed GVA documents and depositions of Stalcup, suggesting the federal regulator was investigating.

Article continues below this ad

Though he’s now using selected documents to assert his innocence, other court records tell a more complex story — and he’s fighting to keep some of those private with requests for courts to seal them from public view.

Attorneys for investors and others suing Stalcup say he is peddling a narrative that’s favorable to him.

“The accountant’s report solicited by GVA is fundamentally flawed and intentionally narrow by design,” Ephraim Wernick, an attorney representing clients who are suing Stalcup and GVA, said of the expert analysis. “It does not refute any of the claims made in our lawsuit.”

Article continues below this ad

Expert analysis

Stalcup was sued last year by Hill Country Hillside Ltd. and other entities associated with investor Bryan Kastleman. He alleged Stalcup was using GVA as his “personal piggybank” by cooking the books. His suit also said GVA had misrepresented the value of 150 properties over several years by misclassifying bad debt, concessions and other negative revenue as assets.

GVA and Stalcup responded that the internal company documents Kastleman relied on were doctored by a disgruntled former employee to suggest records had been falsified.  

Now, GVA is touting a report by former SEC forensic accountant Jason Flemmons that found some of the accounting practices Kastleman called fraudulent were in line with IRS  rules. Some debt had been reclassified, the analysis said, when it became clear it was uncollectible.

Article continues below this ad

“In sum, it is my opinion that GVA’s practice of reversing bad debt expense for the reviewed properties and periods is consistent with applicable IRS rules and not evidence of ‘falsified accounting records,’ ” Flemmons wrote.

In a news release, Stalcup asserted the expert analysis exonerated GVA for its practices.

“This is what we’ve said from the beginning — our accounting followed the rules,” he said.

Chesapeake Apartments, an Austin complex once owned by GVA.

Chesapeake Apartments, an Austin complex once owned by GVA.

Brian Kastleman

But Flemmons also noted that, while the records he reviewed would pass muster with the IRS, investors often rely on more stringent accounting practices that would have required bad debt to be reflected sooner. He was also clear about the limitations of his analysis. While the allegations encompass 150 properties over several years, the analysis covered only three properties over a shorter period. 

Article continues below this ad

Flemmons’ analysis also didn’t address many of the allegations raised by Kastleman, including transfer of company funds to personal accounts, ledger entries that dealt with risk fees and misuse of funds from capital calls that were intended to shore up the health of failing properties.

Those limitations were not discussed in Stalcup’s news release.

As further proof of his innocence, Stalcup has pointed to an affidavit filed by a major investor who sued then settled out of court.  

The affidavit

Overwatch Fund was GVA’s most prolific investor. In 2024, its principal, Ben Loughry, filed two lawsuits alleging Stalcup had hidden assets and extracted $100 million, placing it in trusts controlled by his family. 

Article continues below this ad

Stalcup says Overwatch relied on the same bad data from former employee Zachary Richards — whom Stalcup says holds a grudge after being terminated. Stalcup has sued Richards for, among other things, stealing company data. Richards attorney has said his client was fired for attempting to blow the whistle on GVA fraud.

“Ultimately, Overwatch was unable to identify any evidence supporting Mr. Richards’ allegations that GVA had transferred at least $100 million into trusts in order to defraud creditors,” Loughry said in an affidavit filed in late January. 

Stalcup said the filing vindicates him and GVA by discrediting Richards and other lawsuits that have been filed based on his allegations. 

“He [Loughry] thought it was important to let people know that his claims in his lawsuit were based on Zach’s fraudulent information — and wanted to make amends for it, set the record straight,” Stalcup said in an interview. 

Article continues below this ad

For Richards’ attorney, Michael Lovins, the Overwatch principal’s statement is anything but conclusive. 

“It doesn’t exonerate him at all,” Lovins said. “[Loughry] simply says they didn’t find the evidence of a very narrow allegation,” referring to the transfer of at least $100 million. 

Loughry did not respond to an email requesting clarification. But previous court filings by Overwatch Fund’s attorney Veronica Kendrick cast further doubt on Stalcup’s claims. 

In a Feb. 4 filing, she said GVA and Stalcup were improperly leveraging the court by seeking depositions to drag out litigation with Overwatch “as part of a campaign to pressure Overwatch and its principal into making (false) public statements that GVA can turn around and use in connection with other litigation that GVA has pending against other parties.”

Article continues below this ad

Stalcup said the depositions were a valid attempt to seek evidence that Overwatch violated the settlement’s confidentiality agreement. Overwatch said in filings that it simply sent an email to investors stating the case had been settled. 

‘False narrative’

Court filings also include emails in which Stalcup asks Loughry to “clear the air” by making public statements that the lawsuit was dismissed because Overwatch discovered the allegations were false and Richards’ data fabricated. He offered to drop the request for deposition if Loughry issued the statement. The request struck a nerve. 

“It is amazing you want to dictate my opinion,” Loughry responded via email. “This is exactly what makes headlines. I will do what is right.”

Article continues below this ad

Six weeks later, Loughry told the court he was being coerced to sign documents making statements he didn’t believe.

“Petitioners’ [GVA] goal in all this is clear: to leverage a false narrative about the reasons for the dismissal of the Underlying Litigation to improve their position in the Pending Litigation,” he said, referring to Kastleman’s suit.

Apple Creek Apartments is co-owned and managed by GVA. Investors have suggested in lawsuits that money intended for renovations at properties like this one went somewhere else. 

Apple Creek Apartments is co-owned and managed by GVA. Investors have suggested in lawsuits that money intended for renovations at properties like this one went somewhere else. 

Doug Jensen/Courtesy Doug Jensen

Loughry alleged that GVA and Stalcup, through a public relations campaign, were the ones that violated the confidentially agreement, citing Stalcup’s press releases and media interviews in which he stated that no money had been paid in the settlement. Stalcup said Overwatch had been “duped” by Richards then filed a “sour grapes” lawsuit.

Article continues below this ad

Court filings describe a more complicated settlement structure, with GVA entering a Business Termination Agreement that may have included GVA assets given to Overwatch Fund.

“They [Stalcup] falsely stated that Respondents [Overwatch] had ‘reassessed the facts and come to the realization’ that the lawsuits were meritless, and that this realization was the reason why the lawsuits had been dismissed with prejudice. None of that is true,” Overwatch said in a court filing.

It also says Stalcup is seeking more ammunition in a campaign against Kastleman, “a campaign they are also waging through press releases, investor statements, counterclaims, state bar grievances, and police reports.”

The emails show Stalcup demanded all communications between Overwatch and Kastleman. 

Article continues below this ad

Stalcup earlier alleged that Kastleman had been behind a series of harassing letters to his neighbors, impersonating his wife. Stalcup made similar allegations against investor Doug Jensen. Requests to depose Jensen were thrown out and Stalcup’s team was sanctioned by the judge. But he also filed complaints with Austin Police and filed a grievance with the State Bar against Wernick, Kastelman’s attorney. 

The grievance was dismissed, Wernick said, adding that Stalcup’s campaign against him and his client was an attempt to distract people. 

“Neither his misleading statements about this affidavit nor any of Stalcup’s other paid press releases will work,” Wernick said. “In the end, Stalcup and GVA will be held fully accountable for defrauding Bryan Kastleman and so many others.” 

Article continues below this ad

Stalcup said the Feb. 4 filing from Overwatch, in which Loughry alleged being improperly pressured to sign off on an affidavit, should be viewed through the prism of a heated argument, that things were said that perhaps weren’t meant. All that matters now is the affidavit that Loughry signed, he said, not that Loughry implied aspects of it were false. 

“I just ultimately think with any relationship all that stuff that’s in the past is just in the past, and what is now is now and what is signed by an affidavit is the truth,” Stalcup said.