Letitia Plummer, who is running for the Democratic nomination for Harris County Judge greets supporters during an election night watch party in Houston, Tuesday, May 26, 2026.

Letitia Plummer, who is running for the Democratic nomination for Harris County Judge greets supporters during an election night watch party in Houston, Tuesday, May 26, 2026.

Brett Coomer/Houston Chronicle

Despite Annise Parker outraising, outpolling and outperforming Letitia Plummer in the March primaries, the former Houston City Council member took a surprise victory Tuesday, earning the Democratic nomination for Harris County judge by a narrow margin. 

Parker, a former three-term Houston mayor, blamed the combination of low countywide turnout driven by voter fatigue and high turnout among Plummer’s base, drawn to the polls by other contests on the ballot. Experts agreed, in part, but suggested the race’s broader dynamics — the candidates’ age gap, and the perception of Parker’s establishment politics against Plummer’s progressivism — also spurred the upset.

The March election saw Parker come within four points of avoiding a runoff and securing the nomination outright. Two polls conducted by the University of Houston Hobby School of Public Affairs also pegged Parker as the likely winner, with a double digit lead over Plummer.

Article continues below this ad

But Plummer’s 51% to 49% victory Tuesday bucked both the results of the March primaries and both polls. 

ELECTION DAY: Letitia Plummer wins Harris County judge nomination in major upset over Annise Parker

Political experts and Parker herself pointed to turnout driven by a runoff between U.S. Reps. Christian Menefee and Al Green in the 18th Congressional District and voter fatigue elsewhere in the county as factors in the upset. 

“The 18th Congressional District race drove the vote — in particular, the Black vote,” said Michael Adams, a Texas Southern University political scientist. “I think they turned out in force to support Plummer.”

Article continues below this ad

It’s a theory that’s at least partially supported by voter data, which showed precincts in the district generally swung in favor of Plummer. Some precincts in south Harris County also reported higher turnout that ultimately played in Plummer’s favor.

“While I didn’t think my opponent could beat me, low turnout absolutely could,” Parker said earlier Tuesday evening during brief remarks to news media at Birdie’s Den, where her supporters gathered to watch the results roll in. 

Parker, with more than $1 million raised, also dwarfed Plummer’s $130,000 in fundraising as of her most recently submitted campaign finance reports. 

Plummer’s most recent report posted in March, and she has yet to submit her pre-runoff report. That report was due May 18, according to a notice published by the Texas Ethics Commission. 

Former Houston Mayor Annise Parker speaks to the media as early voting numbers start to roll in on Election Day in Houston, Tuesday, May 26, 2026. Parker competed against Houston Councilmember Letitia Plummer in a runoff for the Democratic primary for Harris County Judge.

Former Houston Mayor Annise Parker speaks to the media as early voting numbers start to roll in on Election Day in Houston, Tuesday, May 26, 2026. Parker competed against Houston Councilmember Letitia Plummer in a runoff for the Democratic primary for Harris County Judge.

Jason Fochtman/Staff photographer

Surpassing expectations

Support for Parker, meanwhile, was most pronounced in the affluent “Houston Arrow” — the city’s westside, the western half of the Inner Loop and the areas just outside it – and in southeast Harris County between Baytown and League City. 

Article continues below this ad

Another factor could be perceptions of Parker as an older, establishment politician, Adams said. Parker served in city government for 18 years, leaving office at the end of 2015. The first openly gay mayor of a major U.S. city, Parker built a reputation as a grounded, fiscally responsible Democrat.

She centered her campaign on a back-to-basics approach focused on disaster preparedness, financial austerity and a promise to fight back against policies implemented by the Trump administration.

Plummer ran as a progressive counterpart to Parker, whose moderate approach she criticized as ineffective in the face of an aggressive Republican federal administration and complicit state officials.

OPINION: Why I’m not surprised Letitia Plummer upset Annise Parker in county judge runoff race

Plummer said Tuesday night that her campaign had “surpassed every single expectation.”

Article continues below this ad

“We have done the work, we have met the people where they are, we have listened to what they want, we are giving what they need and we’re giving them hope,” she told supporters at the Cactus Cove bar in Timbergrove.

Nancy Sims, a political science lecturer at the University of Houston, said Plummer may have appealed to a younger demographic weary of status quo candidates. 

“You’re seeing younger candidates win pretty handily up and down the ballot, and that may extend downward to the county judge runoff,” Sims said. “It’s about letting the next generation take over. You’re seeing it on the corporate side and the political side — but on the political side, this year is especially relevant because it’s happening on both sides of the aisle.” 

Sims pointed to the blowout defeat dealt to incumbent Republican Sen. John Cornyn by Attorney General Ken Paxton, as well as railroad commissioner candidate Bo French’s victory over incumbent Commissioner Jim Wright as evidence that incumbency and age — both once considered campaign assets — may now be liabilities. 

Article continues below this ad