Elizabeth Davis, a restorative practices staff member, greets seventh grader Johnny Ramirez on the first day of school at Dobie Middle School in Austin, Tuesday, Aug. 19, 2025.
Jay Janner/Austin American-Statesman
The Texas Education Agency has rejected Austin Independent School District’s bid for extra time to improve student performance at three North Austin middle schools next academic year, setting the stage for a state takeover of the entire school system.
Dobie, Webb and Burnet middle schools have long struggled on the state’s A-F accountability system, which is based largely on scores from the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness, or STAAR, tests. Each school has scored four consecutive F grades.
Article continues below this ad
State law has mandatory consequences when any campus achieves five failing grades in a row — the state must either close the offending campus or take over the entire school district, replacing the elected board of trustees with a TEA-appointed board of managers.
In March, trustees attempted to give the three middle schools more time to improve their scores, taking advantage of a state law that allows districts to work with external partners to run struggling campuses and “pause” accountability consequences for two years. The Austin school board voted to let the nonprofit Texas Council for International Studies, which runs schools with International Baccalaureate or IB programming, take over operations at Dobie, Webb and Burnet.
TEA does not have the power to void the partnership between AISD and the Texas Council for International Studies, or TCIS. But the agency’s denial of the two-year pause means that if any of the three middle schools scores a fifth consecutive F grade in 2026, the entire school system is at risk of being taken over. Letter grades are typically released to the public in August, although school districts often calculate their scores ahead of time.
RELATED: Texas schools have drastically changed in the last decade. Meet the man behind it
Article continues below this ad
Farid Mendoza colors during a holiday celebration at Webb Middle School in Austin, Thursday, Dec. 18, 2025.
Mikala Compton/Austin American-Statesman
In a letter to Austin ISD Thursday afternoon, a TEA official said the agency denied the 1882 benefits because TCIS’ “uneven” history of academic performance did not meet the agency’s standards.
“A review of TCIS data indicates TCIS has failed to demonstrate a track record of managing campuses to academic success or a track record of significantly improving the academic performance of campuses,” wrote Marian Schutte, TEA associate commissioner over the agency’s department of authorizing and policy.
The district cannot appeal TEA’s decision, according to an agency spokesperson.
Article continues below this ad
Austin ISD Superintendent Matias Segura said the district stands by its belief that TCIS can “lift student outcomes” and is seeing academic improvement across the district because of its commitment to student support.
“We partnered with TCIS with one clear goal in mind: ensuring that the students at Dobie, Webb and Burnet middle schools get the exceptional academic support they deserve,” Segura said in a statement. “While we’re disappointed by the Texas Education Agency’s response, we look forward to sharing additional details that reinforce our certainty that TCIS has the experience and capacity to meaningfully improve student outcomes at these three schools.”
Segura said student outcomes have continued to improve across Austin ISD over the past two years and that the district is seeing “promising trends in our data demonstrating accelerated student academic growth.”
Board President Lynn Boswell did not immediately respond to a request for comment. TCIS CEO Margaret Davis referred questions to Austin ISD, but said the nonprofit “is still very excited about being part of this school community and district and looks forward to continuing the partnership.”
Article continues below this ad
In recent years, TEA has taken over more school districts because of campuses scoring a string of failing grades. In the past year, the agency announced the takeovers of Fort Worth, Lake Worth, Connally and Beaumont ISDs.
A 2017 state law, Senate Bill 1882, incentivizes school districts to partner with charter schools, universities and non-profits by allowing a two-year pause in accountability measures and the potential for extra state funding. The partners must be approved by the agency for districts to access those benefits.
TEA previously approved other school districts to partner with TCIS for 1882 partnerships but said in Thursday’s letter that the approval standards for these partnerships have become more rigorous since a 2020 rule change. To be approved, turnaround partners must be in operation for three years, have managed campuses for multiple years and have a track record of “managing campuses to academic success” or significantly improving campuses’ academic performance. TCIS met the first two requirements but not the last one, according to the letter.
A TEA denial means AISD will not receive the funding or pause. A state takeover means TEA could replace Austin ISD’s local leadership, including the elected school board and superintendent, with state appointees from the Austin area. TEA launched its most notable takeover in 2023 in Houston ISD, outsourcing local decision-making to hand-picked leaders who have cut staff and strictly controlled curriculum.
Article continues below this ad
Struggles at Dobie, Webb and Burnet
Community members listen as Austin Independent School District Superintendent Matias Segura lays out the district’s turnaround plan for Burnet Middle School, May 13, 2025.
Sara Diggins/American-Statesman
The last time any of the three North Austin middle schools passed the state’s accountability system and met standards was 2018. In 2019, each school scored an F. They were not rated in 2020, 2021 or 2022 because of the pandemic or changes to the accountability rating system.
They again scored F grades in 2023, 2024 and 2025. A fifth F in 2026 could lead to major consequences for the entire school district.
Article continues below this ad
Over the past year, the campuses have undergone “turnaround plans,” which are designed to infuse the schools with resources and quickly boost the academic performance of students. The plans overhauled staffing at the schools and emphasized math and reading over other subjects.
Educators at some of the schools raised concerns over pain points in the plans, including staffing arrangements and basic administrative decisions like how to handle late students. One staff member described the plan as “building the road as we drive.”
In December, Segura said some of the difficulties of the turnaround plans were due to a short timeline for creating the plans. Because of statewide lawsuits that delayed the release of the state’s A-F letter scores in 2023 and 2024, the district’s window to submit the turnaround plans to the Texas Education Agency was months shorter than normal. This made developing the plans much harder, Segura said.
TEA officials have previously pushed back on this assertion, noting that districts could still calculate their letter grade without the agency’s official release, giving Austin ISD plenty of time to craft strategies to boost performance.
Article continues below this ad
Who is Texas Council for International Studies?
Texas Education Agency Commissioner of Education Mike Morath discusses the 2024 and 2025 A-F school ratings during a press conference at the William B. Travis Building in Austin, Thursday, Aug. 14, 2025.
Mikala Compton/Austin American-Statesman
When trustees approved the agreement for TCIS to take over Dobie, Webb and Burnet middle schools, they touted the nonprofit as the right partner to improve the campuses.
“Getting with a partner who would throw away all the good things that we have is not what we want to do,” trustee Kathryn Whitley Chu said in March of the proposal. “The Texas Council for International Studies is going to bring in an extra layer of support to all the good stuff. Those schools have gone through so much upheaval.”
Article continues below this ad
TCIS runs 16 schools across San Antonio, Edgewood and Longview ISDs. The nonprofit typically offers IB programming, which tends to focus on teaching middle and high school students globally minded academic programming and is often compared to Advanced Placement or other college preparation courses.
Of the 11 campuses that scored an A, B or C prior to TCIS taking over, five improved their state ranking under the nonprofit’s management. Two schools maintained their scores, and four campuses worsened, according to TEA’s letter.
There were five other schools rated a D or F prior to the nonprofit taking over. Three of those schools “either have a worse rating or failed to improve over the time period that TCIS operated the campuses,” TEA’s Schutte wrote.
Article continues below this ad
Austin ISD’s approved contract with TCIS is set to run through June 2029.