In Joe Espada’s first two years as manager, making the call to bring in Bryan Abreu from the bullpen in the eighth inning of a one-run game with the opponent’s best hitters due up would be a no-brainer.
That’s not the case in 2026.
The Houston Astros manager still called on his right-hander in a tight spot Friday, but Abreu couldn’t come through like he did so many times when he was one of baseball’s most effective relievers from 2022-25.
The 29-year-old, like he has too often this season, struggled to find the strike zone, throwing just two of his 12 pitches for strikes before he was pulled after facing the minimum of three batters. By the time the eighth inning was over, the game was tied, spring-boarding the Milwaukee Brewers to a 5-4 win in 10 innings Friday at Daikin Park.
A look at Abreu’s metrics reveal that he’s not the same pitcher as in years past. The velocity on his fastball is down and the break on his slider isn’t where it has been, both issues Abreu attributed earlier in the season to issues with his mechanics. However, the core problem actually is even simpler: He’s not throwing strikes.
Abreu entered with a 4-3 lead at the top of eighth with the Brewers’ 2-3-4 hitters — Jackson Chourio, Brice Turang and William Contreras — due up. He walked Chourio and Turang by throwing eight straight balls, and with rules forcing pitchers to face at least three hitters or complete an inning, Espada had no choice but to leave Abreu out there. Despite throwing a first-pitch ball to Contreras, Abreu finally landed a fastball in the strike zone. Another ball was followed by a fastball that got Contreras to swing and fly out to advance Chourio and end Abreu’s night with runners on the corners.
Bryan King entered to try to clean up the mess but a weak ground out was enough to score Chourio and tie the game.
“Just gotta create consistency in throwing strikes and staying ahead of hitters That’s kind of been the story for him this year,” Espada said. “When he gets ahead, he’s extremely effective. His stuff is really good. We’ve just got to get him to throw the ball more in the zone.”
Abreu had done a better job of that recently. His ERA finally dipped out of the dreaded double digits earlier this month, and he had put together nine straight scoreless outings even with his stuff not being what it had been in years past.
That’s why Espada had a big decision to make when he opted to go with Abreu. With closer Josh Hader still waiting to make his season debut — and that could come next week — the bullpen uses a closer-by-committee approach with Enyel De Los Santos and King earning 10 of the team’s 15 saves so far this season. De Los Santos had already pitched on back-to-back days, so the Astros wanted to stay away from him Friday, and King was going to be the guy in the ninth inning. With Steven Okert throwing the sixth and the seventh after Kai-Wei Teng’s five-inning start, that didn’t leave a ton of options for the eighth.
One would have been rookie Alimber Santa, who had warmed up earlier, but still entered the day with just one big-league appearance, although that was a perfect two innings in Monday’s no-hitter. Santa ended up being used in the 10th and got saddled with a hard-luck loss when he gave up two fly outs that moved the extra-inning ghost runner from second base all the way home for the go-ahead run.
“I considered him more in the sixth or seventh inning just to pick up Teng or potentially picking up Okert,” Espada said.
That meant the eighth belonged to Abreu, who once again couldn’t find the strike zone and let a potential win over the team with the fourth-best record in baseball get away.