Stuffed baked potato at The Brisket House
J.C. Reid/Contributor
Brisket and sausage stuffed baked potato at Flossie’s BBQ
J.C. Reid/Contributor
The Big Poppa baked potato at Southern Q
J.C. Reid
If it were up to the purists, stuffed baked potatoes wouldn’t exist on barbecue joint menus.
Many barbecue fans and pitmasters believe the only true Texas barbecue comes from Central Texas — specifically, the traditions and techniques forged in meat markets around Austin in the early 1900s.
No sauce. No utensils. No fancy sides. No salads. And certainly no baked potatoes.
Article continues below this ad
Sliced meat — mainly beef — wrapped in butcher paper with a pickle slice and maybe a small container of beans: that’s the stuff of true Texas barbecue.
But times change. Tastes change. Other barbecue styles have their say.
In East Texas, chopped and sauced beef is king, especially on sandwiches. It’s not much of a leap to move that topping onto a baked potato. It’s simply another version of meat and potatoes.
Among less-purist barbecue fans, stuffed baked potatoes have a loyal following. Especially for the lunch crowd, they offer more variety than a plate piled high with rich, fatty meat. A mound of chopped brisket on a steaming baked potato, loaded with shredded cheese, sour cream, green onions and maybe a drizzle of sweet sauce, becomes a self-contained meal. It’s also easy to box up leftovers for dinner later.
Article continues below this ad
Still, many newly minted pitmasters insist they’ll never add stuffed baked potatoes to their menus. They say it doesn’t fit the meat-market barbecue tradition.
Ultimately, though, customers get the final say. Especially in Houston, it’s rare to find a barbecue joint that doesn’t offer stuffed baked potatoes. And while potatoes might seem like a high-profit menu item, the toppings can quickly change the math.
“Ninety-five percent of all stuffed baked potatoes have brisket on them,” says Wayne Kammerl, owner of The Brisket House in Houston. “The potato itself is cheap. Once you add shredded cheddar cheese, sour cream, butter and brisket, the food cost gets higher.”
Stuffed baked potatoes are among the most popular menu items at The Brisket House.
A handful of Houston barbecue joints still resist adding them to the menu — but not for philosophical reasons. For many pitmasters, it’s simply practical.
Article continues below this ad
“We have never offered them,” says Grant Pinkerton of Pinkerton’s Barbecue. “For one, they really slow down the line. It takes an average of two to three minutes to make a potato. In a line of 40 people, if 10 people order potatoes, everyone has to wait an extra 30 minutes.”
Other considerations include space and equipment. The oversized potatoes commonly used today are heavy and require significant storage space, and not every barbecue restaurant has industrial ovens large enough to bake them efficiently.
At Bar-A-BBQ in Montgomery, co-owner and pitmaster Cooper Abercrombie has held off on adding potatoes at the current location.
“We’ve never done them,” Abercrombie says. “We will in our new building, where we’ll have more space to make an incredible one. We don’t want to just make a potato to make a potato. We want to create the best one out there, and that takes time to R&D.”
At Pinkerton’s new Upper Kirby location, there’s plenty of extra kitchen and storage space, but despite lines out the door, there are still no plans to add a stuffed baker to the menu.
Article continues below this ad
Customers continue to ask for them, though, and Pinkerton remains noncommittal.
“I tell people all the time, ‘You bring the potato and we’ll cut the meat up for it.’”
The Brisket House
5775 Woodway Drive; 281-888-0331
Open daily.