An email exchange between the board member and library director became the subject of an ethics investigation.

DALLAS — A city board member was replaced after questioning the Dallas library director’s stance on selling City Hall and the Central Library, according to city documents. Officials claim in documents that an email the board member sent to the director about the two properties violated the city’s code of ethics.



This story continues below.

The Dallas City Council approved sanctions against the board member at its meeting May 27 as part of its consent agenda.

Lorie Blair, the council person who named a replacement board member, said it had nothing to do with any sanctions or ethics complaints.

This all started with a department-wide email from Manya Shorr, the library director, regarding rumors the city had intentions to sell the Central Library, according to city documents. In the email, Shorr explained that nearly $500,000 was being invested in the Central Library. She also mentioned City Hall.

“If the city decides to sell City Hall and the Central Library, that is not my decision,” Shorr said in the Nov. 10 email.

She added: “But I also know the challenges of such a vast space created in the early 1980s when the building was constructed – when no one fathomed what the future of libraries would be. The services we offer are incredibly valuable, as is the work you do with our community. But they are separate from the space they occupy, and that’s what I ask us to focus on. No matter what happens in the future, there will always be a plan for the services to continue, including the unique and valuable collections we have.”

In an emailed response the same day, former library board member Sam Staggs questioned Shorr’s motives and likened her to President Donald Trump.

“The more you talk from both sides of your mouth, the more you sound like Donald Trump,” Staggs wrote. “The reason you were brought here becomes more and more clear: those who hired you were spoken to by powerful developers and by certain members of City Council, as well as by others – e.g., those like Miriam Adelson who envision a sports stadium where City Hall and the Central Library now stand.”

Staggs implied some party in the city received a “substantial gift” to suggest Shorr to be the library director.

He added, “Word is out and plans upset. The fight is just beginning.”

There’s no evidence in the city documents corroborating Staggs’ claim that any party with the city received any gift to appoint Shorr as the library director.

However, according to city documents, Dallas’ Office of the Inspector General investigated the email exchange and determined it violated the city’s code of ethics. Specifically, the city claims Staggs sent the email which “involved personal attacks upon the character, integrity and motives” of Shorr.

Blair informed Staggs on Dec. 8 that she would nominate a new member to the municipal library board to replace him, according to city documents.

Officials with the city’s office of the inspector general met with Staggs and negotiated an agreement to resolve the matter. Staggs completed one hour of ethics training in late February.

WFAA reached out to Shorr for comment. Shorr directed the station’s inquiry to a city public information officer who would only confirm that the City Council would vote on the sanctions against Staggs on May 27.