Graduating seniors are recognized during Houston ISD’s 36th Annual Scholars Recognition Ceremony honoring the district’s highest achieving students, including 68 valedictorians and 42 salutatorians, in Maverick County, Tuesday, May 19, 2026.

Graduating seniors are recognized during Houston ISD’s 36th Annual Scholars Recognition Ceremony honoring the district’s highest achieving students, including 68 valedictorians and 42 salutatorians, in Maverick County, Tuesday, May 19, 2026.

Raquel Natalicchio/Houston Chronicle

Houston ISD’s state takeover began three years ago, when the Texas Education Agency ousted the elected leadership and appointed Superintendent Mike Miles and a nine-member board of managers to oversee the state’s largest school district.

Miles almost immediately launched the controversial New Education System reform model, which has since expanded to about 130 campuses. The NES model includes a standardized curriculum, less autonomy, higher pay for educators and additional support staff for teachers. Given the extra resources, it costs more per student than other HISD schools.

Under the takeover, HISD’s NES schools have seen dramatic improvement on the state’s A-F accountability ratings and growth on multiple state exams, including the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness.

Article continues below this ad

However, the academic improvements have come at a cost. HISD has lost thousands of teachers and staff and seen a larger share of uncertified teachers. At least 15,000 students have left the district, bringing enrollment down to 168,800 and contributing to budget cuts and the closure of 12 schools and two alternative campuses. 

FUTURE 2: 3 years into the takeover, HISD is embracing AI, evolving its signature NES reform model

Some campuses have lost several academic and extracurricular programs as the district has rolled out other initiatives, like Sunrise Centers with free resources for families.

Bob Sanborn, president and CEO of the advocacy group Children at Risk, said the data shows students are performing better in a lot of schools, but recognizes that the changes have been difficult.

Article continues below this ad

“I think the messenger and the way the message is delivered isn’t always the best way, and I think that obviously we would much rather have an elected school board who chooses a superintendent of their own choosing, not one of the state’s, but I think that you’ve seen really nice results,” Sanborn said.

As more districts throughout Texas face state takeovers, here’s what’s been lost and gained in HISD since June 2023:

MIKE MILES: HISD’s Superintendent was paid consulting fees after state ban. What happens next?

Wheatley High School triggered HISD’s state takeover in 2019 after earning seven straight failing grades. Two years into the district’s overhaul, the Fifth Ward campus improved from a “D” to a “B” by 2024. District leaders cite academic gains at Wheatley and other schools as evidence that the intervention is working. 

Article continues below this ad

Wheatley is one of dozens of schools that have dramatically improved since the takeover began. In 2025, HISD had zero F-rated schools and 17 D-rated ones, down from 121 failing schools in 2023. 

To exit state intervention, HISD must eliminate campuses with multiyear failing ratings. In 2025, it cut the list to four schools. Miles has since aimed higher, pledging to have only “A” or “B” rated campuses by 2027. 

“Wheatley has been doing really well, and I think you have some administrators who are here that are really committed and focused on our students,” said Carolyn Moore Wright, president of the school’s alumni association. “The community as a whole, we’re super excited about that.”

EDUCATION TECH: From Chromebooks to iPads, here’s what tech policies look like at Houston-area schools

HISD has also seen widespread STAAR improvements and had some of the most-improved campuses in Texas in 2025, according to annual ratings from Children at Risk.

Article continues below this ad

“It’s worth it when low-income kids are doing better, when neighborhoods that didn’t have good schools previously now feel like, ‘Wow, we have something,’” Sanborn said. “We have seen the data, and I believe the data, and I think that what we’re seeing is kids are doing better.” 

Still, the nonprofit also found HISD had some of Texas’ least-improved campuses. It’s also difficult to track schools’ year-over-year progress through accountability ratings alone because so many factors change, said Toni Templeton, a senior research scientist at the University of Houston’s Education Research System. The state changed its accountability formula in 2023.

Historically, academic gains from state takeovers often diminish over time. This year, student growth drove HISD’s improved accountability ratings, pushing those grades to the top even as many students remained behind and performed below statewide averages in reading and math.

For Courtney Isaak Pichon, chief executive officer of education nonprofit Good Reason Houston, growth on national tests like the Measures of Academic Progress gives her hope that progress will continue.

Still, the nonprofit is focused on long-term success beyond test scores. Fewer than 20% of HISD students earn a living wage out of high school. As HISD works to exit state intervention, Isaak Pichon said it needs to focus on lasting progress with community buy-in.

Article continues below this ad

“There is a lot to celebrate with this growth,” Isaak Pichon said. “The progress is real, but the work is far from finished.”

Student enrollment losses

While HISD has seen academic gains since 2023, it is losing students at an accelerated pace. Campuses in Miles’ NES reform model have experienced significantly steeper drops.

For example, as Wheatley has improved its state rating, its enrollment has plummeted 19% to just under 500 students. In total, the district has lost more than 15,000 students, or about 9%, in the past two years, prompting the closure of over a dozen schools.

HISD’s enrollment was already declining by about 2% each year in the five years prior to the state takeover. Since the 2023-24 school year, the district has lost students at roughly double that rate, by an average of about 4% each year.

“Moving into a school district to try to improve it, and having that many students leave is a clear indicator that the change that the state issued is not a welcome one,” Templeton said.

Miles said on Houston Matters in May that enrollment declines are a national phenomenon, and he attributed losses in NES schools to several reasons, including economic mobility and immigration declines. In the Houston area, Miles said Aldine and Pasadena ISDs had larger percentage enrollment declines compared to HISD.

“NES has been a huge success, and the achievement is undeniable,” Miles said. “(At) the end of the day, parents want their kids to read, write, and do math more. … Kids and families are celebrating what is happening in those schools.”

Multiple parents, however, have told the Chronicle that they’ve pulled their child out of HISD largely due to dissatisfaction with Miles’ changes, including NES, the district’s standardized curriculum, and rising staff turnover.

Jessica Flores, a former HISD parent, said her daughter would regularly come home crying from third grade in Tijerina Elementary School due to stress. Even though it was not a designated NES campus, she said the school followed much of the NES model. 

“They had no recreational time,” Flores said. “They were forced to do schoolwork from the moment the bell rang (in the morning) to the moment the bell rang at the end of the day. It was schoolwork, schoolwork, schoolwork, with no break. Just straight working out of packets.”

After watching her daughter’s mental health suffer, Flores hit her “breaking point.” She pulled her out of the classroom at the end of the 2024-25 school year and enrolled her in Pasadena ISD, where she’s thrived. Despite their new 30-minute drive from the East End to Pasadena, Flores said she doesn’t see a circumstance in which she would re-enroll in HISD.

Miles’ reforms have reached far beyond test scores and classroom instruction. Programs that once defined schools have been dismantled, while Miles is launching new initiatives that will likely continue to reshape how students learn.

In 2021, Valerie Mayfield enrolled her children at Mark White Elementary School — Texas’ first public dual language French program. In February, the district quietly said it would end the program after first grade, replacing instruction that was split evenly between French and English with an elective offered twice weekly. 

The Briarmeadow campus has lost almost a quarter of its enrollment since the takeover began, despite the efforts of a tight-knit group of parents from across the city.

“We stayed with the sinking ship,” Mayfield said. “We were so pumped at the beginning of the year, like we’re going to save it. … We did everything, and still, (we’re) devastated.”

Grappling with budget deficits, falling enrollment and Miles’ vision for education, several other program cuts have followed. The district has ended its International Baccalaureate designations at some campuses, phased out career and technical education offerings and cut back library services. Two specialized campuses have closed. Change has been particularly profound at NES campuses, which follow tight schedules to maximize time for instruction.

Even as some programs have disappeared, Miles has introduced new initiatives. Instead of placing wraparound specialists at every campus, HISD launched eight Sunrise Centers for families in need, which the district said has served more than 86,000 families since they began in 2023.

At NES campuses, the district has introduced new “Art of Thinking” courses, which aim to teach problem-solving and creative thinking and, in some cases, replace social studies offerings. 

While several school groups have faced last-minute field trip cancellations since the takeover, the district’s annual student travel program is sending around 950 students to Nashville, Washington, D.C., Costa Rica, and the Dominican Republic this year.

Program changes will continue next year as students at 12 closing schools are assigned new campuses. Around 5,000 students in certain special education classes will also move to new campuses next year, an overhaul that has drawn parent pushback and a federal investigation.

HISD will also launch a new “Kinder Bridge” program at some schools next year, serving as a year between kindergarten and first grade for students who are behind in reading. By 2028, the district plans to require students to meet certain literacy benchmarks before advancing to third grade.

In place of certain popular career programs, HISD plans to expand its Barbara Jordan Career Center and build another “Southside Launchpad” by 2028.

Miles’ signature reform model is also expanding, with nine schools joining NES next year. Nine more will join Miles’ new Future 2 program, which he said will prepare students for a future where “AI will be ubiquitous.” Miles plans to have up to 100 Future 2 campuses by 2031, with courses on topics like AI tools and the study of cultures, plus music lessons, sports and community service projects.

It’s unclear whether current programs at those schools will be cut or altered in the process.

Hartman Middle School art teacher Kelvin Goodings has spent the year helping his students showcase their work across Houston with full support from his principal.

But Hartman will become a Future 2 campus next year, and HISD’s fine arts department – which had just begun to stabilize — lost its director in May.

As he looked on at his students’ artwork exhibited in Artechouse Houston, he wondered what his program would look like this time next year.

“I don’t know, because we don’t know,” Goodings said. “A lot of unanswered questions.”

While HISD has seen higher test scores and accountability ratings, it has also lost experienced employees, and new hires dominate its current workforce, according to analysis by the Houston Chronicle.

Employees with three years or less of consecutive employment make up the largest share of current district employees by tenure. Just under half of HISD employees were hired after the state takeover began on June 1, 2023, according to a Chronicle analysis of district records. HISD did not respond to requests for clarification and comment.

More than 2,300 of HISD’s roughly 10,000 teachers left in June 2025, and 800 teachers left that school year from August 2024 through May 2025, according to a previous Chronicle analysis.

Miles said he does not think teacher turnover is a problem.

“What you want in a school district is to have to retain your most effective teachers, and to bring on enough teachers so that you don’t have vacancies at the beginning of the year, and teachers who can still get the outcomes you want,” Miles said on Houston Matters in May. “And so, we are retaining our highest-performing teachers.”

Teachers have told the Chronicle that rigid expectations in lessons, a lack of support, frequent observations and long work hours influenced their decisions to leave. Hundreds of teachers have also been non-renewed for reasons including low performance and excessive absences.

Celia Fragoso, a Golfcrest Elementary School teacher, stayed for less than a school year. She started in HISD as a learning coach in August, while she was working toward her teacher certification. Within months, the school assigned her to be a teacher apprentice, then a second-grade bilingual teacher, then a kindergarten teacher.

“I struggled a little bit, and instead of coaching me or providing me with the resources necessary so that I could thrive … the principal just came in, looked around, and gave me the lowest score possible, and did not even notify me that she was going to come in,” Fragoso said.

She said she tried to follow up with the principal to meet the growth plan she was assigned, but received the one-on-one coaching she needed only once. In March, she was told she could resign instead of being terminated for excessive absences. She had 11 absences — one day over the district’s 10-absence rule, emails show. Records show she resigned.

Tameeka Jacobs, Hartman Middle School’s former special education chair, said the role was an opportunity to support middle school students after teaching and supporting elementary school students. She was never in education for the pay, but the “nice salary” of $92,000 influenced her decision to join HISD in January 2025. She said teachers could benefit from more direction and clear contacts for support.

But in the fall, HISD restructured its special education department, moving the division under academics after its deputy chief left and separating instruction from compliance for the federally mandated services.

“There was a whole new compliance team,” Jacobs said. “It really changed the culture. No one really knew who to reach out to if they needed something. I think teachers not having the support — being held to this expectation without the real support and training — is what’s driving some of our teachers away.”

The staff turnover has been felt on some campuses, even as academics have improved. 

At Wheatley, families gathered under murals of famous alumni as they welcomed their third principal since the takeover began. Constant change has cast a shadow over some of Wheatley’s academic gains, Wright, the alumni president, said. The school has lost some of its rich cultural identity, including pep rallies and homecoming traditions, and enrollment has declined sharply.

While she has hope in their new principal, Wright doesn’t believe Wheatley will reach true success until the takeover ends. 

“Students need some stability. It’s like any household — all those constant changes, they can’t focus,” she said. “I think when they transition to an elected board, we’ll be able to communicate and make them notice.”

Data reporter Taylor Nichols contributed to this story.